Weekly Poll: Favorite Arctic Monkeys Album

Rank em, tell us why, or just pick one.

Link to all of the other polls here. You can leave suggestions for new polls there or here. Whatevs.

 

TBHC
Humbug
WPS
AM
FWN
SIAS

one of my fave bands ever ever. Suck It and See is the only one I don't love love.

 

TBHC
Humbug
FWN
WPS
SIAS
AM

the definitive ranking

 

FWN has my favorite songs, but I love TBH&C

 

Whatever... is just a classic. There’s not much more that can be said about it.

FWN has some massive songs on it, though I probably return to it the least.

Humbug pushed them into new, exciting directions and I’m still in awe of some of the choices they made on this one. Reset the bar.

SIAS is so incredibly underrated, and maybe has my favorite final stretch of three songs ever. Perfect summer album.

AM does not get the credit it deserves, probably due to over saturation, but it really is a more thoughtful record than people want to admit. Every song on that album could have been one of the year’s best singles. Just absurd.

TBHC has probably jumpstarted my imagination more than any piece of media in the past five years. Probably Alex Turner’s best lyrics to date. In equal measures absurdly funny, and deeply melancholic. I just love it. And it’s been said a million times, but to follow up a global hit like AM with something like this is so gutsy. Took me a few listens, but by now this has settled into the #1 slot for me.

 

I've only ever listened to Whatever People Say I Am.

 

Whatever People Say I Am
Humbug
Favourite Worst Nightmare
AM
Suck It and See
TBHC

 

You couldn't be more right about SIAS. It got my vote due to nostalgia and how that album crystallized Summer 2011 in my brain. I definitely listen to TBH&C way more, but SIAS is one of those records that sends me on a mental time warp every-time I hear it, or even a song from it.

 

Favourite Worst Nightmare
Whatever People Say I Am
Humbug
AM
Suck It and See
TBHC

 

I guess I'll post it here again

Whatever People Say I Am
Humbug
Tranquility Base
Favourite Worst Nightmare
AM
Suck It And See

 

Tranquility Base Hotel and Casino
Humbug
Favourite Worst Nightmare
Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not
Suck It and See
AM

 

Same ranking hell yeah

 

Whatever People Say I Am
Humbug
Favourite Worst Nightmare
AM
Suck It and See
TBHC

 

trash

 

while I do respect putting any of their albums at #1, I hope everyone putting TBHC last knows they are incorrect

 

This but i’d switch TBHC and Suck It and See

Whatever People Say I Am
Humbug
Favourite Worst Nightmare
AM
TBHC
Suck It and See

Their first 3 records are just so fucking good, it’s unreal

 

Honestly one of the more difficult polls since every one of their records has something unique to offer. Just a really fun and dynamic discography to go through.

 

The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala absolutely rules, the perfect spring song to drive around with windows down

 

whatever ppl say i am

but...

i guess im in the minority since i love suck it and see. probably my second favorite release from them

 

1- Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
2- Favourite Worst Nightmare
3- AM
4- Suck It And See
5- Humbug
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
327- Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino

 

wait, that's not how numbered lists work!

 

Update:

1- Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
2- Favourite Worst Nightmare
3- AM
4- Suck It And See
5- Humbug
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
327- The Car
328- Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino

 

Tranquility is great

 

As hard as I tried Tranquility does nothing for me. Stays dead last in my ranking still.
But The Car is fantastic. The first half is one of my favorite 5 song runs in their discography.

 

Favourite Worst Nightmare
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
Humbug
AM
Suck It and See


…..


The Car and Tranquility are both tied for the very bottom for me. A few decent tracks on each but nothing I return to aside from Four out of Five.