I could see the redone version winning New Surrender. The original one winning NTFP? Not so sure about that.
I'm down to start a Yellowcard bracket in a few days. I'm not really familiar with Anberlin's material (except a couple songs like Feel Good Drag) so I'll leave that one to someone else.
I could be tempted to do an anberlin bracket, but as those who followed Silverstein know I tend to let the rounds stay open pretty long, so as long as people don’t mind.
Congrats to Earth Will Shake! I'm be so down for Yellowcard or Anberlin too. YC has a huge discography so that'd be long but a lot of fun. Fin would def take most of Anberlin bracket lol
Yellowcard would be pretty much as long as Thrice. It's 8 albums assuming we start at One for the Kids. I don't even consider Midget Tossing and Where We Stand as the same band and nobody ever talks about those anyway. We can also put the two EP's for good measure.
Great job with this one Very worthy winner in The Earth Will Shake! It's such a special song that is wholly unique to Thrice. Definitely one of the first songs I would share with somebody who is new to Thrice. Had a lot of fun despite joining in late at The Alchemy Index!
For anyone who liked the bracket game and enjoys Jack’s Mannequin, I started a bracket for Jack’s Mannequin. Feel free to join us herehttps://forum.chorus.fm/posts/1564262
Ok so this will be a 4 rounds Palms + Deeper Wells bracket. All the matchups have been randomized so there might be some unfortunate matchups. Round 1: Only Us Vs. The Grey Just Breathe Vs. My Soul Stumbling West Vs. Beyond the Pines In This Storm Vs. A Branch in the River Hold Up a Light Vs. Blood on Blood Everything Belongs Vs. A Better Bridge