The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild NA Tony Hawk's Underground Okami The Witcher III: Wild Hunt Super Mario World God of War (2018) NA
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Fallout 3 Guitar Hero Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas Diablo III Super Mario World God of War (2018) Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
Dragon Age Inquisition Bioshock Infinite Tony Hawk's Underground Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas Diablo III Mario Kart Double Dash God of War (2018) Red Dead Redemption
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild N/A Tony Hawk's Underground Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas Diablo III Super Mario World Dragon Quest VIII Red Dead Redemption
we hit our first tie between San Andreas and Okami. i think most would view them as games that were primarily played on PS2, so i used those MC scores. San Andreas got a 95 and Okami a 93, so San Andreas advances.
Red Dead beating MGS3 and Fallout 3 beating Bioshock Infinite are probably the two most painful results so far.