Left off the Christmas album because I didn't have space. Rank em, tell us why, or just pick one. Link to all of the other polls here. You can leave suggestions for new polls there or here. Whatevs.
This might be the toughest poll yet. This band has had such a fun run. Everything from Anatomy to Five Score could be the pick for me. Probably going with MMHMM because it brings back a lot of fun memories.
Forget and Not Slow Down Five Score Air for Free Mmhmm Collapsible Lung Three Lefts Anatomy Relient K
Ive always been surprised by this site’s fascination with FANSD. I like it, but I like all of Five Score, MMHMM, and Two Lefts more than that album and didn’t realize that was apparently a hot take until coming here
This band has so many incredible songs, and records like Mmhmm and Five Score mean so much, but as an album I think I love FANSD the most.
MMHMM Forget and Not Slow Down Air for Free Five Score Two Lefts... Anatomy Relient K Collapsible Lung
Forget and Not Slow Down by a pretty large margin, love that album so much. Can't believe it's already a decade old.
Mmhmm Five Score Forget --- Relient K, Anatomy, Two Lefts all in here somewhere. I've only heard them a few times each and kind of jumble them together so --- Collapsible Lung Air for Free
Right? Such a clear memory being in high school, putting the CD in the stereo for the first time, following along with the lyrics in the booklet
Forget And Not Slow Down is still perfect to me but this is a hard decision with quality albums such as mmhmm, Five Score & Air For Free. And that's ignoring the nostalgia for the first "proper" album I ever heard, Two Lefts, which essentially launched me into a whole new world of music.
Air For Free Forget and Not Slow Down MMHMM Two Lefts Don't Make A Right... But Three Do Five Score and Seven Years Ago The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek Collapsible Lung Relient K AFF is incredible, didn't get nearly enough love. I was ride or die for FANSD forever but AFF tops it now for me
The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek Mmhmm Five Score and Seven Years Ago Two Lefts Don't Make a Right...But Three Do Forget and Not Slow Down Not well versed enough in the rest to rank them.
FANSD was my favorite album for years and is still very dear to me. AFF and mmhmm are very good and I enjoy many songs from them. The rest of the albums are whatever.