Since I missed one last week, double dose this week! Rank em, tell us why, or just pick one. Link to all of the other polls here. You can leave suggestions for new polls there or here. Whatevs.
Killing Time>Shudder>Vacancy>S/T>Cult>TWW>S&C Love all their albums except S&C, but Killing Time is pretty perfect all the way around for me. TWW has the most songs that, when i look at the track listing, I honestly can't remember what they sound like, despite me listening to it basically as much as all their others
S/T for me. Adore that record from front to back, and it houses my two favorite Bayside songs, Dear Tragedy and Don’t Call Me Peanut.
Killing Time>TWW>S/T>Vacancy>Shudder>Cult>S&C I like all of their albums but front to back Killing Time is the most consistent for me.
I'm gonna need to go back and listen to all of their stuff. I fell off after the first record. Always loved it tho. Not sure what happened with the rest.
Killing Time is my favorite by far, TWW is #2. I’m a big fan of Gil Norton’s production, so it’s not really a surprise how much I adore KT.
Doing the bracket for this band got me to revisit the whole discog but I’ve struggled really hard to get into anything post s/t. but the lyrics from those first 2 are so cringe-y.
love to see Killing Time on top as it fucking should be KT S/T TWW Vacancy?? Cult Shudder Sirens But really Bayside is the most consistent fucking band, all of these are so solid and ranking them outside of killing time is sorta splitting hairs for me
S/T all the way. I harp on them a lot for being too heavy handed with it in their live sets, but there’s a reason they keep returning to that well. Record is just bangers from front to back
Sirens will always be my favorite because it will always be my first. S/T is also high up there for me, but it's more than just nostalgia. There isn't a dull song on that album, and the fact that the band still plays so many songs on it proves its talents. I'm not too surprised by Killing Time, as I see it as the band's most consistent album from the middle of their career onwards. Sirens and Condolences Bayside Vacancy Killing Time Shudder The Walking Wounded Cult
Killing Time by a country mile. That has nothing to do with how little I love the other albums, but everything to do with how much I love that one.
I can’t say I’m shocked Cult is the only record without a vote. I love everything this band does, so I still enjoy that record a lot, but I’m not sure I’ve ever heard a Bayside fan call it their favorite.
I assumed we were just joking around here. I still love Cult. There’s no such thing as a bad Bayside record.