Your Controversial Food Opinions • Page 795

plenty of places have mint Oreo but I get it was the whole package

 

Have you had the Trader Joe's Horchata ice cream? It's insanely good.

 

Trader Joe’s ice cream rules. I love their pumpkin ice cream and their peppermint Joe-Joe’s ice cream.

They also used to make this cherry chocolate ice cream made from soy milk that was absolute fire. But I don’t think they make it anymore

 

Oh yeah for sure. But none of them compare, sadly

 

nah but I'm intrigued now. next time I'm there I'll have to pick some up

 

I love Tate's cookies and I love a thin / crispy / snappy cookie over something gooey and soft any day in general.

It's local, but a chain here has a Brambleberry crisp ice cream and that's probably the best ice cream I've ever had. To go along with the above, I like texture in ice cream, and I really dislike anything that's all one note (like chocolate on chocolate - too rich).

 

Brambleberry Crisp is so good

 

TJ's horchata ice cream fucking rules. I also really liked their lemon ice cream, it had really strong lemon flavor.

I like straight up mint ice cream, no chocolate chips or anything

 

I love Tate's cookies

 

You know I used to dunk on people who said that vanilla ice cream was their favorite, but you bring me a well-made vanilla soft serve that can be the base for some delicious toppings and I'm a happy camper

 

Honestly, some basic, nice vanilla ice cream hits the spot.

Nothing beats some fancy vanilla bean ice cream with pie

 

If you're going just base flavors without stuff mixed in you can't top high quality coffee or vanilla.

 

I used to be a big vanilla ice cream fan but I feel like all the ones I've tried over the last couple years are just overwhelmingly sweet with little actual vanilla taste

 

I want this

 

I do not want a crispy cookie. I want a soft and chewy cookie.

 

The best cookie has a nice, mild crisp on the outside with a great, chewy inside.

But if not that, I prefer my cookies chewy

 

I prefer chewy cookies as well but there's just something about Tate's that works for me.

 

Freeze dried candy kind of sucks and just tastes like stale candy

 

Freshly baked cookies better soft and chewey
Store bought packaged cookies better crispy

I don't want a soft Chips Ahoy or soft Oreo i will throw that shit in the garbage

 

yup

 

Well of course an Oreo wouldn’t be soft.

 

I dunno. Drop an Oreo in milk until it’s soft…pretty good.

Oreo still the most mid cookie

 

that’s cake

 

I mean yeah that’s how you should eat Oreos