Why did I just wade through 2 pages of posts about album rankings for two bands that are not Yellowcard
Wouldn't call TWY overrated, I think a lot of people have soured on them. And so have I, so I think at this point my opinion pretty much matches the consensus. When I thought of what I'd consider the most overrated AP bands, the ones that readily came to mind were Brand New, MCS, and Fall Out Boy.
I think FOB post hiatus is underrated honestly. I think their pre Folie stuff is overrated. Honestly Yellowcard and Thrice are probably the band's that get the most love that I don't really care for.
I liked the last two Fall Out Boy records at first, but haven't gone back to either in a long time. I don't really care for anything pre-hiatus from them.
While we're talking about other bands, the new Switchfoot album is forgettable except for three songs. So that sucks.