I think I’m now at the point where I like this album more than Southern Air. Just going through this bracket, I think there are more A+ songs.
Weird, I didn't get any notifications for this thread the past few days, so I missed some stuff. The Deepest Well Fragile and Dear One Bedroom Lift a Sail Illuminate
Transmission Home (both great songs so this was a little tough) Fragile And Dear My Mountain (This was really hard, One Bedroom is great but I absolutely love this song) Make Me So (Hot take i know) Illuminate So when I first heard this album I wasn't too into it, and i don't know why. Maybe it just wasn't the right time for a record like this for me or something. Since then it has grown on me immensely and is now probably my third favorite Yellowcard album.
Transmission Home Fragile and Dear One Bedroom (dislike both of these songs though) Lift A Sail Illuminate
Deepest Well (It's weird because Transmission was one of my favorite live songs of there's, but just doesn't appeal to me quite as much on the album. Still a really good song though) Fragile and Dear One Bedroom Lift A Sail (Make Me So may be my least favorite YC song and LAS is a top 5 song for me so, pretty easy) Illuminate (2nd best song on the album behind Lift a Sail)
Same. TH has an extra punch live that is missing on the album version for me. Also I know Memphis May Fire is hated on this site, but I had never heard of them before their singer guested on Deepest Well. I checked out their discography because of that song and I really like their first 2 albums, so Deepest Well means more to me on that level as well.
Transmission Home Fragile And Dear One Bedroom Lift A Sail Illuminate Transmission Home vs. The Deepest Well and Lift A Sail vs. Make Me So were the only difficult ones for me this round.
Final scores: Transmission Home - 12 The Deepest Well - 6 Fragile and Dear - 17 Convocation - 1 My Mountain - 8 One Bedroom - 10 Lift a Sail - 17 Make Me So - 1 Madrid - 2 Illuminate - 16 Round 2: California Vs. Transmission Home Fragile and Dear Vs. One Bedroom MSK Vs. Lift a Sail Crash the Gates Vs. Illuminate