This is absolutely huge, it could actually fit on PW and I don't think a first time listener would bat an eye.
Not feeling I'm a Wrecking Ball much. It's too repetitive for my taste, and it breaks the flow of the album to my ears. Whereas Leave a Light On made sense as a sort of conclusion to that first act, this one doesn't quite work here, I don't think.
Yeah, they sure do.. and musically I think the song's fantastic, but the idea behind it leaves a bit of a bad taste in my mouth. Not towards the band themselves, just the way they felt about this subject.
That's why I think I would've just released Rest in Peace and saved the rest for later, that strategy makes most sense to me.
absolutely adore empty street, favorite song from the big if demos - bunny & me and always almost come close though. the big if version of empty street was one of the songs i had in constant rotation as this horrifically toxic relationship i had last year slowly imploded over the course of numerous months (i have so many stories that i can tie in some way to yc, it's kind of ridiculous.) it's definitely right at home on this album, though i could see it on paper walls as well. i would never in a million years take dear bobbie off paper walls, but i think empty street would fit nicely in its place. yeah in hindsight it seems like a pretty perfect way to insure a quieter lead-up to a fantastic send-off.
I was almost positive Fields & Fences was going to include some sort of career reprise, but it's perfect as it is. I'm blown away by that one.
That's gotta be their best closer, right? Up until now I would've given that title to Southern Air, but I feel like the scope and build of this one just destroys even that song.
Favorite songs after one listen are surprisingly easy - Rest in Peace, A Place We Set Afire, Leave a Light On, Fields & Fences