Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by Henry, Feb 16, 2019.
Not putting their first two records because no one is picking those.
I almost picked WYTTSY, but I went with Southern Air.
Having trouble deciding between Paper Walls and S/T. Think I'll still go with PW, but it's really close for me
Super close between Southern Air and Paper Walls, but had to go with Southern Air. It just felt so right when it was released.
It’s Southern Air for me. Yellowcard at their career peak.
I have no qualms with being the only person to pick One For the Kids.
its paper walls u fools
WYTTSY is such a great album from start to finish. Ocean Avenue and Southern Air are close second and third.
Seriously, I always say Southern Air is my favorite, but lately WYTTSY has come really close.
Lights and sounds, easy
I adore that album so much. That album reminds me of rainy days in LA.
One For the Kids is when I got into them so just for nostalgia sake alone that will always be my favorite. Ocean Avenue was an incredible follow up but I kind of fell off after that. I’ll need to go back through the rest of their discography judging from the range of votes here.
Man, Lift a Sail was so underrated.
L&S, hands down
Voted for Paper Walls, but Dear Bobby is still one of the worst songs I have ever heard.
I LOVE Dear Bobbie!
I like Dear Bobbie way more than Ten.
Agreed. I love it, but I'd put it maybe 5th overall.
Lift A Sail
Lights and Sounds
I historically have unpopular YC opinions in this community, haha
This is a tough one. I went with Ocean Avenue for nostalgia but if you cut Dear Bobbie I think Paper Walls takes it.
Southern Air. Best they’ve ever sounded. Was a good culmination of everything up to that point and is easily their most consistent album
I go back and forth between Southern Air and Lift a Sail, but I’ll show some love for the latter here.
I grew up on Ocean Avenue and Lights and Sounds but WYTTSY was such a big album for me. Its incredible from top to bottom
Drives me crazy that it gets grouped into a “standard reunion record”. It ranks above Paper Walls for me. Its that good.