Weekly Poll: Favorite Sum 41 Album • Page 2

Underclass Hero has their best song they've written in my opinion but the nostalgia factor of All Killer does it for me.

Chuck does have my favorite song musically though

 

what song?

 

I think Speak of the Devil is the best song on the album, but not the best they have ever written.

 

With Me

 

what I want to do is go back to these polls a year later and see if the latest album a band released really changed their opinion on what record is their favorite. Recency bias is a big thing on this site, so it kind of alleviates that.

 

Based on what I've heard so far this should almost certainly land right in the middle for me to start. Above their last 3 albums. It would take quite some time to see if it could possibly move up

 

I somehow knew you were going to say it was that one!

 

It's so good and I feel like it's not a very common song amongst their fans.

How DID you know?

 

Fair point

 

It was my guess too haha

 

Chuck is the best for me. Next is Does This Look Infected?

 

All Killer will always come in first for me every time. You simply can't replicate that album, during that era, during that point in my life. Obviously a personal preference. I love Chuck and all, but it's never been the golden standard for me like many have considered it to be. All Killer is just a perfect example of quality pop punk in the early 2000's from front to back.

 

Had to go with All Killer because that was my introduction to them. But I love everything they’ve done - funny thing is a bunch of their albums I really get into years after they were released. Remember not liking Underclass Hero when it was released, and then it was one of my favorites. “Re-discovered” Screaming Bloody Murder a week or two ago and I can’t for the life of me remember why I wasn’t blown away by this album when it was released.