Forget and Not Slow Down Air for Free Mmhmm Two Lefts Five Score (these two are basically equal) Anatomy Relient K Collapsible Lung
Skimming through the replies, man, we're really the only ones who don't hate Collapsible Lung, lol. I'd probably move Air for Free up one, but otherwise, I think I'm in the same boat ranking wise.
It's a solid album! Lol. It's got a few great songs and a few bad ones. Honestly think it's crazy people have it below the debut. Air for Free is about even with Five Score for me, I think it just has one or two more that I don't love. Empty House is probably my favourite RK song at this point though.
Lots of nostalgia with this band for me, and difficult for me to rank because I like all their albums. I think FANSD is their best work though!
I just want to take a moment to appreciate Two Lefts. IMO the oddest part of this poll is that it has zero votes alongside self-titled and CL. That album is like Anatomy but refined in every single way.
I think the only problem I have with Anatomy is the closer is probably their weakest ever. Still my personal favorite album of theirs, so many absolute gems on it.
Yeah, I just think they usually nail closer tracks and Less Is More never felt quite as strong. Love it as well though.
Yeah I'll still put it as a bottom tier closer for them, but in terms of Anatomy I definitely don't think it's the weakest.
Oh man, I almost voted for it! I jammed it just this weekend and I can still sing almost every word. My copy was a pale blue, CD was a slate blue color. I know there was a pink one as well, any others?
Mmhmm will always be my favorite. Perfect time in many ways for both me and the overall genre/scene. Love Forget... a lot though.
Mmhmm is my favorite even if I think FANSD is probably their “best”. Seeing that I broke a temporary tie between the two made me very happy, both great records