Weekly Poll: Favorite Pink Floyd Album

They've got a ton of music, but I pretty much expect the discussion to be ruled by three records.

Rank em, tell us why, or just pick one.

Link to all of the other polls here. You can leave suggestions for new polls there or here. Whatevs.

 

Still need to do a bunch of acid and watch this movie.

 

It's Animals

 

Meddle.

 

Relics has some of their weirdest shit

 

Wish You Were Here

 

they're remarkably consistent but it's probably animals for me. the final cut is supremely underrated.

 

I'll go Dark Side. they're all great tho

 

animals!!!!

 

Also going to go with Animals. Meddle is also an underrated gem.

 

meddle is the best in the run post-piper and pre-dark side

 

Meddle is definitely my favorite pre-dark side album by a long shot, but I’ve never been into anything before Meddle. Wish You Were Here, Animals, and Meddle are probably my favorites. Dark Side and The Wall are of course phenomenal but the others have hit differently.

 

pipers at the gates of dawn is incredible

 

set the controls is also an awesome awesome album

 

yeah it’s a bit scattered imo but has some truly great songs

 

Keep Talking a favorite lesser appreciated song

Have A Cigar goes off, my fav single from them

Also I think I threw Marooned in like 90% of mix CDs I burned for friends or girls I liked or w.e lol just a tiny lil island interlude round track 10

 

lol i just put "marooned" into one of my mixes a few months ago

i used to hate the division bell because i thought it was corny but since then i've become a corny person and i love it now, about as close as you can get to an ambient floyd record in parts. "high hopes" is also the best song ever

 

my exceedingly silly floyd ranking:

animals
wish you were here
the division bell
piper at the gates of dawn
dark side of the moon
meddle
a saucerful of secrets
atom heart mother
obscured by clouds
the final cut
ummagumma
the wall
more
[huge gap]
a momentary lapse of reason

 

listen to the final cut again

 

animals
wish you were here
piper at the gates of dawn
dark side of the moon
the final cut
meddle
the wall
obscured by clouds
saucerful of secrets
division bell
atom heart mother
ummagumma
momentary lapse of reason
more
endless river

 

i love the final cut!!!! it was my favorite floyd album at one point

 

The Final Cut is awesome and so few people realize it

Meddle and Obscured by Clouds are underrated too

 

I think A Saucerful of Secrets would probably be in my top three. really love that one

 

Piper at the Gates of Dawn is my favourite, closely followed by Wish You Were Here.