Weekly Poll: Favorite My Chemical Romance Album

Rank em, tell us why, or just pick one.

Link to all of the other polls here. You can leave suggestions for new polls there or here. Whatevs.

 

Three Cheers > Danger Days > Black Parade > Bullets for me

Three Cheers was basically the soundtrack to one of the best times of my life in 2004-2005 so I guess nostalgia plays a part in that, but every song is super good on it while the other records have a couple skippable tracks

 

Black Parade for sure!

 

Excited to stand in solidarity with my danger days truthers

 

Slight edge to TBP over Three Cheers.

 

TBP > 3 > Bullets > Danger

 

Bullets
3 Cheers
Danger Days
Black Parade

 

WHEN I WAS

 

Justice for Bullets

 

Three Cheers and TBP are super close but I give the edge to Three Cheers. I think those two albums alone show how versatile and forward-thinking the band was especially compared to their contemporaries. Danger Days is third and has some of the biggest bops. Bullets is last because something has to be but it’s still a great listen despite the rough production.

@Henry you a monster for not including Conventional Weapons you coward

 

everyone just wants me to include b-side albums lol. I'll have to consult the band threads before making these from now on.

 

Nah I’m just joking but CW is a great collection of songs. Throw “Fake Your Death” on as a closer and it’s a damn fine faux fifth album

 

Three Cheers always

 

Danger Days FTW

 

three cheers > bullets > black parade > danger days

 

Yup. No competition for me

 

Bullets by far.

 

Still really don’t like DD. Conventional Weapons would come in 3rd for me behind TBP and 3C.

 

oh hey my favorite band, wasn't sure if one had been done for them yet. Gotta be Three Cheers but every album is valid

Three Cheers > Bullets/Black Parade (too hard to decide) > DD

Conventional Weapons goes between Bullets/Black Parade and DD I think. Everything they've done is fantastic.

 

Black Parade
Three Cheers
Conventional Weapons
Danger Days
Bullets


I love them all except for Bullets, which has never really grown on me

 

Danger Days for sure. I love CW & TBP, but I almost never go back and listen to Three Cheers or Bullets anymore.

 

Matt’s drumming for MCR was a huge influence on me when I began playing, and it’s not that I don’t enjoy The Black Parade onward, but I do tend to stick to their first two albums because I just still love hearing his work on them.

 

DD for sure! Love every record of theirs though

 

what’s up!!!

 

Never thought I’d choose Danger Days, but I did. I listen to it the most.