Weekly Poll: Favorite Fall Out Boy Album

No major releases this week, so let's do a big one.

Be sure to comment with your thoughts!

 

I have to go with Infinity on High. Ten years ago it would’ve been one of the first two. I haven’t liked anything since they’ve come back.

 

FAD is still their best.

 

Take This To Your Grave

 

Folie by a good amount. Also want to show AP/AB some love as my second fav since it's so underrated.

 

From Under the Cork Tree. Maybe for nostalgia purposes and I know every word haha.

 

From Under the Cork Tree

 

Fad, Sr&r, infinity me thinks

 

Take This to Your Grave is the only album I'd give above a 3/5 to. Folie a Deux is underrated amongst the general public, but not here, because that's my second favorite album of theirs.

 

FAD's been my favorite since I've had it inside me (so to speak) for a few months

 

I’d be ok with either FUNCT or IOH at #1, and I played both of those to death on the crappy PC in my basement growing up.

Personally I find Folie to be very overrated. That’s probably my least favorite of theirs, but it might just be that it came out around the time that I thought I was “too cool” for FOB

 

FAD is fantastic and their best. Cork Tree and Infinity are tied for me. Beauty/Psycho after that. I really did not like Mania at all. TTTYG would probably be universally panned if it was released today. I also have no idea what Save Rock and Roll is. How did I miss an entire album haha. wow

 

From Under the Cork Tree. Was never able to get into anything after Infinity on High.

 

Infinity on High, then, now, and forever.

 

I went SR&R. There's a lot tied into it that I find hard to articulate, but it's the one I come back to the most.

 

From Under the Cork Tree. That shit is in my DNA

 

Folie > From > Infinity > SR&R > Take > American > Mania

 

Infinity > Folie > FUCT > SRAR > AB/AS > TTTYG > Mania

 

FUTCT. They lost me in recent years.

 

FAD for me.

Though out of all of my favorite bands, FOB are probably the only one where my favorite record is not a clear decision.

A lot of nostalgia clouds TTTYG and FUCT. IOH was a record i initially dismissed but have come back to. I genuinely think MANIA is superb.

I don’t know. It’s tough.

 

TTTYG will always and forever be my #1. FOD is 2nd.

 

They lost me after Infinity and I think the last 3 have been pretty bad.

 

Corktree was a HUGE formative album for me so I can't see any other of theirs topping it. One of my best friends gave me my CD copy of this back in 7th grade for my birthday and it stayed in my walkman for a good 3 months straight.

 

Infinity > Folie = Cork Tree > Take This To Your Grave (this would be honestly higher if the lyrics aged well... which they didn't) > all the other ones

 

Folie. Those songs are just massive. They mastered what they were trying to do on that album and it shows.