Weekly Poll: Favorite Coheed & Cambria Album

With their new album coming out this week, lets look back at their discography.

I seriously didn't know half of these releases existed.

 

In Keeping Secrets!

 

GA for me.

 

It could be any of the first three depending on the day but I went IKS

 

SSTB closely followed by IKSSE3.

 

Good Apollo I. It's so close with IKS, but Good Apollo just encompasses every aspect I love about them. They're basically my favorite band, so picking one of these albums is so incredibly tough though.

 

I went with IKS, though truthfully I could answer with any of the first three. These guys have been one of my two favorite bands for sixteen years, and nearly all of their records have special places in my heart in some way or another.

 

SSTB for me.

Anyone who votes outside the first 3 gets a side eye.

 

Sorry but Descension just does it for me. The first three have very high highs but also a good amount I don't care for. There's only really Iron Fish I don't love on Descension and 2's My Favourite 1 is my fav Coheed song.

 

If I hadn’t voted for GA, my next pick would have been one of the Afterman records.

I come back to those three more often than any Coheed record by a sizable margin.

 

In Keeping Secrets and nothing comes close until the day I die

 

If I hadn’t voted for IKS I would’ve voted for NWFT. Let the flaming begin

 

1. IKS
2. GA1
3. SSTB

But SSTB probably still has almost as much quality as everything else they've put out since those three. Don't get me wrong, they've had some great songs, but none of the post-GA1 albums come close as a cohesive unit.

I could listen to any of the first 3 straight through any day of the year.

 

In Keeping Secrets was the album that got me hooked, but Good Apollo surpassed every expectation. Modern rock opus if I've ever heard one.

 

Album gets unfair hate because people didn't like the direction they went in at the time. It's full of rippers and some of their catchiest choruses though and I still love it.

Honestly the only Coheed album I don't love is YOTBR, and that's more due to the baffling production choices on it

 

sstb 4ever

 

GA 1 closely followed by GA 2. Both are phenomenal.

 

IKS is the one.

 

IKS, but GA1 is also very close for me. Honestly their first three albums are near perfect.