Although Pines is probably the better song my reasoning for my vote is Earth is overall the better Thrice song. Not only is it a live staple(for good reason), but it also is a choice cut to show someone getting into Thrice imo.
What were all the winners? If I remember: Phoenix Ignition Avenge and Awake The Dead Colder Cash and Cold Hearts The Earth Will Shake Firebreather (Don't remember what the winner was from Air/Earth, probably Daedalus) The Weight Anthology The Long Defeat Beyond the Pines That would make a sweet short setlist.
Phoenix Awake Cold Cash The Earth Will Shake Firebreather The Weight Anthology Long Defeat Pines Alchemy was one big bracket
Final scores: Beyond the Pines - 7 The Earth Will Shake - 9 Beyond the Pines gave a good fight, but The Earth Will Shake remains our Champion! Thank you for participating this week! Green Day bracket coming Monday.
Edit: I think I screwed up what I was going for. I have a bad memory, I guess. I was going for the Captain Planet call out. But the two videos I just watched had Fire second. I failed!