Thrice: To Bracket Everywhere is to Bracket Nowhere Bracket • Page 57

Happy you broke it the way you did! Anthology was such a perfect parting gift for fans when they went on hiatus, and is a total jam besides.

The Long Defeat
Hurricane
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

The first two matchups

 

The Long Defeat
Hurricane
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

The Long Defeat
The Window (best track on the album IMO)
Wake Up
Whistleblower

 

Stay With Me
Hurricane
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower


The Long Defeat vs. Stay With Me should've been the final. Hot damn. I voted for the one I don't think will win, but also my favorite song on the album by a bare margin over the other.

 

I don't want Stay With Me to die in Round 1, but it probably will :( My ideal final round would have been Hurricane vs Stay With Me

 

The Long Defeat
The Window
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

The Long Defeat
Hurricane
Wake Up
Whistleblower

 

This Window is pretty easily my favorite song on the album

 

Defeat
Window
Salt
Whistle

 

Stay With Me
The Window
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

I always get chills when I get to the "There's no wind and there's no light, there's no song you hear at night" part of The Window.

 

Current scores :

The Long Defeat - 7
Stay With Me - 2

Hurricane - 5
The Window - 4

Wake Up - 2
Salt and Shadow - 7

Whistleblower - 9
Seneca - 0

 

The Long Defeat
The Window
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

The Long Defeat
Hurricane
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

It makes sense that Seneca isn’t getting any votes but it’s a great little break. I hope the next album has more of Riley’s post-rock influence.

 

Stay With Me
Hurricane
Wake Up
Whistleblower

 

The lack of votes for Stay With Me makes me sad :(

 

Love Stay With Me but the end of The Long Defeat is what wins it for me.

 

I like Stay With Me more than The Long Defeat, but the first two matchups are easily my top 4 from the album.

 

If The Window wins this round the second match up next round will be tough, The Window and Death from Above are the two best tracks in my opinion. Would probably have to go with The Window though.

 

I’ve got my votes for the next round all figured out no matter how this shakes out.

 

The Long Defeat
Hurricane
Salt and Shadow
Whistleblower

 

Stay With Me

Hurricane

Salt and Shadow

Whistleblower

 

Stay With Me all the way. Long Defeat is great but stay with me is a perfect track imo