They are all good. I think the cool thing about them is the gave each kinda of Thrice fan a place to gravitate towards. Of my favourite 5 songs from the Alchemy Index are Air(2), Water (1), Fire (1) and Earth (1), which I think is pretty cool.
yeah on Major Minor the cover is brown (earth), the lyrics are about (water), dustin was (fire)d from his church, and they recorded the album in a room with (air) in it. incredible.
I hope the next album is a straight up cover of Palms but all the guitars are palm muted the whole time
I love everything the band does, so I'd be down for any one of these. but the 40 min Hold a Coors Light would probably be the best choice
Oh same, I love them all of course, just the other three a little more. 3 of my top 5 are Fire, Burn the Fleet, Messenger and Firebreather. Daedalus and Child of Dust probably round it out.