I'd jam it. I love Cataracts so I might switch it out with Call It in the Air, but other than that I think it may be mine too.
I gotta say, aside from the tour they did with Brand New and mewithoutyou my favorite tour may have been where O’Brother and Moving Mountains were support.
I was at both of those (if you saw my huge post with most of my Thrice stuff). The BN-mewitoutyou tour wasn't my favorite Thrice tour since they played such a short set, it just means a lot to me since it was the start of my Thrice fandom. My favorite was probably when they toured TBE Thrice Setlist at The Pageant, St. Louis Edit: or the fake Farewell tour, that setlist was a monster and it was part of my bachelor party.
I felt like Atlantic was a big first move to introduce Riley’s ambient cool music into Thrice that has evolved into a things like The Water EP, Circles, Salt and Shadow and so on. Again, to each their own.