Thrice - Palms (September 14, 2018) Album • Page 334

Does this count?

 

Apparently this is actually a fan made video, the non-live stuff is from an Alexisonfire music video haha

 

Ya i know lol. I thought there was a legit music video for that song but can't find it so i guess i misremembered

 

Their best video and legit video for Silhouette

 

Ed hates TAITA (the song), too.

 

There was a time where I kinda liked jamming Silhouette during sound checks and stuff, but man, I'm tired of that song. They're addicted to its live impact on the crowd. It's their "Brain Stew."

 

I don’t mind that one live, goes off

 

Worst
As the crow flies
Wake up
Hold up a light
Deeper wells
Listen through me.

Meh
Image
Lion / wolf
Promises
Blood on the sand
Call it in the air

 

M/m has a killer ep in it
Alchemy index bats .950
Beggars is almost perfect
Vheissu is the best album of the genre
ARTIST is repetitive but the greatest gateway post hardcore album of all time.
TBE has a few too many radio rock moments
Palms could have used some of these deeper wells tracks and it would be beggars light

 

It's incredible live.

 

I can’t imagine a Thrice show without them playing Silhouette.

 

TAITA (title track) will always be a weird one for me. It sounds so much like a Sum 41 song that I wish the former covered it. I'm not a fan of Dustin's vocals on it.

 

yeah I'd tentatively agree with some of the takes in here in that Artist songs sound 100x better on House of Blues Live, between Dustin's better vox and the production

 

The Sky is Falling
Call It In The Air
As The Ruin Falls
Atlantic
Wake Up

Honorable Mention: Deadbolt

 

To be fair though, all songs from that live disc sound pretty much better than album versions. It's not really fair to pick out Artist.

 

fair point, but I'd say the Artist songs have the biggest gap between studio and live quality

 

Artist and Illusion songs I'd agree with. That just happens though with older songs. Most bands play their older stuff better because they've grown and voice matures. Dustin's voice became it's best during The Alchemy Index IMO.

 

I'd be down to hear that! Side note, so happy we are getting new Sum 41 soon!

 

We talk too much
We talk in circles
'Til we're all spinning 'round
Reaching for rings
On this merry-go-round

 

Worst post Illusion

The Grey
Deeper Wells
Listen Through Me
Cataracts
Digging My Own Grave

I think I burned myself out on the Grey, but that one and Deeper Wells just seems real tired at this point.

Top Alchemy song - Daedalus
Favorite Alchemy Element - Water

 

On board with all of this except i think TBE is near flawless

 

Reported

 

This is the best take I've heard on this album. Hard to disagree with.

 

EPs are only 6 songs or less though right? How does that work on an album with 11 great songs?

What would your M/M EP be?

 

It's a good question, and my picks may not be what the conventional answer would be:

Yellow Belly
Promises
Call It in the Air
Words in the Water
Anthology
Disarmed