Thrice - Palms (September 14, 2018) Album • Page 230

well i didn't want to overwhelm her with all the heavy stuff, so a bit of everything.
and i was debating if the closer would be defeat, pines, or salt/shadow.

 

I'd probably try and show off some of their different styles, which could scare some off, but probably:

-Yellow belly
-The Messenger
-Black Honey
-Burn the Fleet
-For Miles
-Red Sky

6 songs is super hard though.

 

Hurricane
The Weight
Circles
Firebreather
Dust of Nations
Beyond the pines

 

Completely opposite of mine but very nice!

 

i guess i should switch the long defeat as a closer and replace it with 'in exile'...

so:
only us
the window
stare into the sun
for miles
digital sea
in exile

 

Hurricane
The Earth Will Shake
Of Dust and Nations
Black Honey
Night Diving
The Whaler

 

Earth
Black Honey
The Whaler
Daedalus
Dust
Pines

 

I'd probably do one from every of their most recent releases.

For Miles
Digital Sea
At The Last
Yellowbelly
The Window
Everything Belongs

That was tougher than I thought.

 

This album ended up being a huge disappointment for me.

 

This, Underoath, and Death Cab were all hugely disappointing for me this year

 

Take out Death Cab and sub Mae and I’m with you.

(Although Mae is growing on me super fast)

 

The worst Thrice record is better than the best Underoath record.

 

The best Underoath album (Lost In the Sound) is amazing, but I do agree. That's not a slight on Underoath at all though, if that is what you were tying to do. Thrice is just that good.

Edit: To be fair, I always forget to count First Impressions and Identity Crisis. I actually think a lot of Underoath's discography is better than those. From Illusion and on though, I agree.

 

Define the Great Line is better than M/m in every universe.

 

Nope.

Lost in the Sound of Separation is better than (At least) First Impressions and Identity Crisis. No contest.

 

I live in an universe where M/M is awesome and beloved though, so leave my universe out of it

 

I agree and edited my post to reflect.

 

No you don't. Delusions aren't universes.

 

Dannnggg, I thought when I saw you quoted me that you'd go for the obvious "must be a lonely universe" but you burned me harder than I thought.

My response to that though is "anything is possible when you believe hard enough "

 

I know M/M gets brought up all the time on this thread and the same back and forth happens typically, but I just don't get how an album with so many strong songs isn't considered a great Thrice album, let alone just a great album.

Listen Through Me and Call it in the Air get brought up a lot, but lets say they are indeed trash songs (they aren't), does a few bad songs make the whole album bad?

 

I mean, with Death Cab, you had to have seen that coming

 

I liked Kintsugi so I was pretty bummed by the new one

 

Have you even listened to an underoath record?

 

I am sorry, my friend

 

Kintsugi is very good and so is Thank You For Today.

Palms is great.

Major/minor is half great/half godawful.

New Underoath album might be fine in a vacuum, but it's not a good Underoath album.

New Mae is awesome.