The Clincher over The Meddler would've been really easy for me. Ouija Board vs. Door To Door Cannibals was a tough one. I think I give the slight edge to Ouija Board just because I've listened to that song more and I like that album more too. Sleep Apnea over The Clincher (Version 103) would've been another easy pick. I would've also voted for Family System over Straight Jacket Fashion.
I was recommended a live video of Point #1 and decided to look up the setlist from that night since I was surprised they still played that song. Looks like they were touring Sci Fi Crimes. Chevelle Setlist at Egyptian Room at the Murat Centre, Indianapolis Holy heck, this looks like such an amazing set. Maybe best I've seen from them?
Ok, everyone - this is it! Thank you for your participation these past several weeks. I hope you’ve all enjoyed yourselves. Round Three Final Totals: The Clincher - 6 Door To Door Cannibals - 0 Sleep Apnea - 1 Straight Jacket Fashion - 5 ——————— Final Round: The Clincher vs. Straight Jacket Fashion
Super awesome final round! I also need to echo: Thanks my dude @bachna84, I loved fan boi-ing out about one of my all time favorites for a few weeks!
To be fair, in the digital age you can add any song to any album. I def listen mixes more than full albums.
For anyone interested, I will start a Billy Talent bracket tomorrow right over here: Afraid of Brackets (Billy Talent bracket) • forum.chorus.fm
That’s it - The Clincher wins it all! Final Totals: The Clincher - 6 Straight Jacket Fashion - 0 —————— Thanks again for everyone’s participation! If you’re looking to fill your bracket void, please consider participating in the Billy Talent bracket! There are also ongoing brackets for Good Charlotte and Angels & Airwaves if you’re interested. I plan on taking off for a bit and then running an Incubus bracket sometime later this summer!
That would be a ton of fun! Esp since people seem to be divided on if the band fell off with Crow Left of the Murderer or that is their best one.
I really like If Not Now, When? But the band definitely had a bit of a “fall from Grace”. Still love them though.
I personally love SCIENCE though Morning View but dropped off, even though Light Grenades was a good step in a better direction. They came up in the Thrice thread a while ago (before it super went to shit) and it was super divided with people saying Crow and after was their best, so it should be a fun time!