Log in or Sign up

Become a Member

Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

The Wonder Years - Sister Cities (April 6, 2018) Album • Page 20

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by JaytotheGee, Jan 29, 2018.

Search

CAC3 Jan 30, 2018

Dog

cwhit said:

if i had the TWY 7" rip i wouldn't send it to anyone we all know what happened last time i shared a link i found on the internet of an unreleased twy song

What song did that end up being?
CoffeeEyes17 Jan 30, 2018

Reclusive-aggressive Prestigious

i think Palm Reader is my favorite TWY song and probably their best if i HAD to pick 1
DeviantRogue Jan 30, 2018

Take arms, it'll all blow over Prestigious

sophos34 said:

fake history doesnt hold up

Jake nooooo

beachdude42 and Zac Djamoos like this.
MFA Jan 30, 2018

See you in hell, or see you when I see you. Prestigious

sophos34 said:

fake history doesnt hold up

both your hot takes have hit me right in the gut this was a terrible idea

beachdude42 and sophos34 like this.
If you like this website, please upgrade your account to remove the ads or safelist the website in your content blocker, we will not be able to exist otherwise.
CoffeeEyes17 Jan 30, 2018

Reclusive-aggressive Prestigious

uh oh jason v casey round 3 nuke the thread ill see you all in the prestigious forum

beachdude42, ECV, Contender and 4 others like this.
cwhit Jan 30, 2018

still emperor emo Prestigious

CAC3 said:

What song did that end up being?

it was the AP premier of PTSD when the site crashed, saw a link to it posted on TWY's fb while the site was still down

i will not be discussing this further this is a taboo topic

CAC3 likes this.
Anthony_ Jan 30, 2018

A (Cancelled) Dork Prestigious

CoffeeEyes17 said:

i think Palm Reader is my favorite TWY song and probably their best if i HAD to pick 1

Cigz n Saintz
sophos34 Jan 30, 2018

Prestigious Supporter

MFA said:

both your hot takes have hit me right in the gut this was a terrible idea

you havent seen anything yet

beachdude42, MFA and cwhit like this.
DeviantRogue Jan 30, 2018

Take arms, it'll all blow over Prestigious

TBB is the greatest production tragedy this decade

beachdude42, pauljgreco, Zac Djamoos and 1 other person like this.
cwhit Jan 30, 2018

still emperor emo Prestigious

there there is still probably my favorite
MFA Jan 30, 2018

See you in hell, or see you when I see you. Prestigious

DeviantRogue said:

TBB is the greatest production tragedy this decade

it is known
CoffeeEyes17 Jan 30, 2018

Reclusive-aggressive Prestigious

jake pls dont hurt me u know how much i love this band let me have this moment jake pls dont burn the thread down im sorry jake pls

beachdude42, Anthony_ and sophos34 like this.
If you like this website, please upgrade your account to remove the ads or safelist the website in your content blocker, we will not be able to exist otherwise.
sophos34 Jan 30, 2018

Prestigious Supporter

DeviantRogue said:

TBB is the greatest production tragedy this decade

have you heard hebrews

AndrewSoup, beachdude42, FTank and 2 others like this.
Micah511 Jan 30, 2018

We reach for the longest shadow

Jason Tate said:

No, that's not what I'm saying. Re-read it. What I said was that people don't wanna admit there's a lot of sound influence from a band they don't like in a band they do like. And you've described here a good example of why people like one band over the other ... a big part of that is time and place. Doesn't change the overwhelmingly obvious influence, down to melodies that are straight up right out of that era. Hell, Chad Glibert helped write early Fireworks songs ... of course it's there. I get why people don't wanna talk about the linage though. NFG wasn't cool to anyone under a certain age.

Chad produced All I Have to Offer... and there is obvious NFG reference there, I have no qualms admitting that. I assume you can't point me in the direction of a Fireworks song released after that album and an NFG song that shows this? Also, I like NFG just fine, but they are a surface level pop punk band, nothing more, nothing less. Fireworks really felt like more, especially from a lyrically standpoint, and musically on OCL.

EDIT: I responded before seeing your subsequent posts, carry on.
cwhit Jan 30, 2018

still emperor emo Prestigious

i am sad the sinai vessel album that came out last year sounded so bad those songs were very good

Brenden and Contender like this.
DeviantRogue Jan 30, 2018

Take arms, it'll all blow over Prestigious

My pop punk hottake is that Polar Bear Club was the best band doing it while they were active.

GEM37, beachdude42, JBoch and 3 others like this.
cwhit Jan 30, 2018

still emperor emo Prestigious

PBC was so good live

but also i don't see the sonic comparisons between them and any of these bands and it was interesting that they were sort of ushered in with that
Snoblin Jan 30, 2018

Goblin Person Prestigious

OhTheWater said:

Fireworks have done nothing for me. A few songs on their first release were cool in late high school. Fell off very quickly, didn't fuck with the releases everyone fell all over. There are very few bands from that era of pop punk that stick out to me at all. Honestly prefer songs by like Man Overboard and A Day To Remember more than most of the others.

Haven't enjoyed a Wonder Years release in forever. The first Aaron West tape was dope though. Respect Dan as a person and lyricist. The Upsides and Won't Be Pathetic were super influential for me in late HS/Early college but I never return to that either. Maybe I'll enjoy this

This causes me physical pain.

beachdude42, marioeatworld and Micah511 like this.
sophos34 Jan 30, 2018

Prestigious Supporter

DeviantRogue said:

My pop punk hottake is that Polar Bear Club was the best band doing it while they were active.

the album where dude stopped singing rough was horrible

beachdude42, FrankieThe4th, JaytotheGee and 1 other person like this.
Jason Tate Jan 30, 2018

chr.us Staff Member

Micah511 said:

Chad produced All I Have to Offer... and there is obvious NFG reference there, I have no qualms admitting that. I assume you can't point me in the direction of a Fireworks song released after that album and an NFG song that shows this? Also, I like NFG just fine, but they are a surface level pop punk band, nothing more, nothing less. Fireworks really felt like more, especially from a lyrically standpoint, and musically on OCL.

The chorus melody to "Arrows" is straight up old NFG.

Micah511 likes this.
If you like this website, please upgrade your account to remove the ads or safelist the website in your content blocker, we will not be able to exist otherwise.
SmithBerryCrunch Jan 30, 2018

Trusted Prestigious

PBC was not really pop punk

beachdude42 and MexicanGuitars like this.
sophos34 Jan 30, 2018

Prestigious Supporter

until homie had to sing like he was in real friends they were more melo hardcore
Snoblin Jan 30, 2018

Goblin Person Prestigious

Jason Tate said:

I don't wanna listen to it again. I listened this morning and hated it.

(You can see my rant in the Q&A thread in the supporters forum.)

This is the hottest take. Can't even get close. Burns too much.

GEM37 likes this.
sophos34 Jan 30, 2018

Prestigious Supporter

the best melodic hardcore band is a wilhelm scream, everyone else is just a worse version of them

beachdude42, felipecardel, ECV and 4 others like this.
MFA Jan 30, 2018

See you in hell, or see you when I see you. Prestigious

sophos34 said:

you havent seen anything yet

just fuck me up

You must log in or sign up to reply here.

Advertisement blocked. This website is run by one person and these ads are the only way we can keep publishing. If you like this website, please consider becoming a supporting member to remove the ads or safelist the website in your content blocker, we will not be able to exist otherwise.