I would go for this. I feel like my thought process was just 'what would I want the band to play at their last show ever?' and I think this gels as best as it could. Feels YFW and Deja-lite, probably intentionally. Soco Vices 1996 Jaws Swimming Theme Millstone You Stole Noro Sink Guernica Brother's Song The Boy Who Blocked His Own Shot Welcome To Bangkok At The Bottom Nobody Moves Jesus Sowing Season Battalions Degausser Limousine You Won't Know (Encore) Moshi Moshi (Acoustic) The Quiet Things That No-one Ever Knows
Biggest gripe is that you left "Bought a Bride" off of the list. You balanced this out though with the inclusion of "Noro." That is currently my "white whale" track for them as I have yet to witness it live and love it so completely.
I've seen Brand New twice and neither time did they play Soco or Play Crack The Sky. It hurt a little.
I was also thinking they could just stand around on stage scowling while the Shone album plays through the speakers.
A surprising amount of this list came from one of the best shows I've ever seen a band play, them at Ommegang Brewery last year
1. Sowing Season 2. Gasoline 3. Okay I believe you, but my tommy gun don't 4. Limousine 5. Guernica 6. Jude Law and a semester abroad 7. Sic transit gloria 8. The no seatbelt song 9. Degausser 10. Bought a Bride 11. Brothers 12. I will play my game beneath the spin light 13. You won't know 14. Not the sun 15. The quiet things that no one ever knows 16. You stole 17. Millstone 18. The archers bows have broken 19. Handcuffs 20. At the bottom Encore 21. Magazines 22. Am i wrong
1. Vices 2. The Shower Scene 3. Tautou 4. Sic Transit Gloria 5. Millstone 6. Not The Sun 7. Good Man 8. 1996 9. At The Bottom 10. Sowing Season 11. Guernica 12. Flying At Tree Level 13. Moshi Moshi 14. Archers 15. You Stole 16. Logan To Gov. Center 17. Play Crack The Sky 18. Limousine 19. Nobody Moves 20. Soco Amaretto Lime 21. Good To Know... 22. You Won't Know