Kelvin is easily the most annoying. Judy fucking rules. People saying they don’t like her kinda feels like when people say female stand-ups aren’t funny. She’s not any more over the top than Danny McBride.
Edi outshines McBride in this by a long shot for me and I think he’s one of the funniest people alive.
I like female stand ups so I am not sure where you are going with that. I watch plenty of it and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is one of my favorite shows. But yes, Kelvin is weird and Adam pretty much plays the same character in everything.
Danny obviously rules but it’s nice than in gemstones he doesn’t revolve the show around his own character, the shared screen time for all actors works very well
The scene where Judy and BJ were in the diner and she was describing he first “boyfriend” was pretty funny.