The Pie Wars • Page 14

man I forgot all about this thread

 

the north remembers

 

glad this in an old thread. for a few minutes i thought you all went 8 pages in on pie in like 2 hours
very glad to see pumpkin on top
very very glad to have missed this cheesecake as a pie debate

 

Pumpkin won, as it should have

 

yeah you’re lucky you didn’t have to deal with the people who think it’s not a pie

 

I’m glad some of you had sense

Best part is I saw this thread and immediately my brain was like “god damn I want cheesecake” hahaha

 

have we done a is Cheesecake a Pie? thread?

I've lost track

 

i mean i have nothing but time if someone wants to explain how it's a pie

 

ahh yes, we have

 

I mean, it's not but it damn sure ain't cake. it's a tart, if anything

 

i've never heard anyone say the correct answer before

edit: after the rabbit hole i just came out of, this is not the correct answer

 

I just don’t see what’s so different about tarts and pies lol. If you offered me a piece of pie and gave me a piece of tart I’m not gonna say “oh wait no I don’t want this, this isn’t what I thought you meant” lol

 

I get that lol

 

And my other argument was if Cheesecake is a tart, then how the hell is key lime pie a pie? Wouldn’t that also be a custard tart?

Same with pumpkin pie! What makes THAT a pie and not a tart? Texture and construction wise it’s alot like cheesecake.

 

I got nothin'

 

idk, but i don't think a cheesecake is a tart anymore

 

Olallieberry Pie is the only true winner.

It should be in season any day now... if you can find it, try it. Best thing on earth.


Bought a cherry pie from a local bakery for $27 the other day, just looked so damn good... and it was, but i'll never spend that much on a pie again.

 

Tarts use different dough though. Cheesecake def ain't a tart

 

fair enough. so what do you think it is then?

 

Cheesecake-pie-tart-lette

 

a magical anomaly

 

I know we joke a lot about how “x is a sandwich” or “x is a burrito” and stuff but in all seriousness cheesecake is a pie, for all the reasons @Randall Mentzos put forward.

 

you won't hear an argument out of me

if anything I want it to be a pie

 

warm apple pie