The Menzingers - Hello Exile (October 4, 2019) Album • Page 70

If that bracket were run here it would be casey v lookers and i think lookers would win

 

I love Casey but I’m surprised how many people would pick it over Obituaries or Gates when we’re talking OTIP

They all fucking rule though

 

How is a mixing error glorious

 

how is it an error? I like it and fits with the song

 

it sounds like absolute shit and if thats on purpose then will yip is a hack

 

Yeah I don't like it at all

 

Here is a bigger version

 

“Could a error in the final cut ever be enough I’ve been mixing for your love

Since the day that we mixed I’ve spent every second in Pro Tools fixing it up”

Wow can’t believe they sung about said track feature in the album v relevant

 

There's almost no chance it's not intentional. I wouldn't have done it, but it doesn't bother me.

 

Mexican Guitars vs. I Was Born
Casey vs. Burn After Writing (Damn, Burn vs. Your Wild Years was tough)
Good Things vs. Chamberlain Waits
Rodent vs. Strain Your Memory

I Was Born vs. Burn
Chamberlain vs. Rodent

Burn vs. Rodent

Burn


After the Party vs. Sunday Morning (damn)
Midwestern States vs. Sculptors
The Obituaries vs. Time Tables (Holy fuck)
Lookers vs. In Remission

Sunday Morning vs. Sculptors
Time Tables vs. Lookers

Sunday Morning vs. Time Tables

Sunday Morning


Burn vs. Sunday Morning

Sunday Morning = Winner

 

Sunday Morning is getting beat by The Bars on the reddit post what the fuck

 

My final two in the bracket ended up being Casey and Obituaries. I think I would give a slight edge to Obituaries but that's tough

 

Casey is a perfect song

 

The bars is good

 

did it myself and my final 4 is Wild Years (tough match against Mexican Guitars), Good Things, Gates, and Lookers.

I'd pick Wild Years and Lookers, then probably pick Lookers to win it.

 

with how low mixing budgets are these days i would not at all be surprised if it was an error

 

Ha, fair enough. I admittedly don’t know a lot about that stuff!

 

It sounds intentional to me but I don't know about that stuff

 

If that’s really how it went then that’s fucked up

 

I think it’s intentional, but It did take me a few listens to get used to. Not sure I love it for sure

 

i definitely think its both intentional and a really weird choice

 

i had to listen to figure out what you were all talking about lol

i think it sounds intentional but sloppily done lol

 

all of you are misunderstanding me. the fade itself is intentional. the way its done is an error. its uneven, it was either supposed to be corrected and forgotten about or will yip sucks at fading

 

ok yes this is what i think

 

not really. songs are mixed multiple times and then they pick the best pass. entirely possible they picked this one but forgot the fade in on it was fucked up but couldnt go back and correct it