The Menzingers - Everything I Ever Saw (July 17, 2026) • Page 4

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by 333 GANG, Apr 27, 2026.

  1. Barcara

    Regular

    Such an incredibly dependable band for me, everything they have put out since Impossible Past has made my top five for the year (usually top 3).

    New song is just more of them doing their thing, and I love that exact thing.
     
  2. Chcurry182 Apr 29, 2026
    (Last edited: Apr 29, 2026)
    Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

    Like the sunburst but will hold off to see what’s on their site.

    Edit: wonder why their site doesn't have any at this point.
     
    screwflanders and Oviedotiger like this.
  3. m32137

    Trusted

  4. Jim

    Trusted Supporter

    I like this song better than heroes but still doesn’t do much for me and now I can’t unheard “when we were young” since it’s been pointed out haha
     
    fredwordsmith and screwflanders like this.
  5. dqwinny

    THRILLHOUSE Supporter

    i couldn't wait and got the sunburst. Assuming something better will drop now
     
  6. VanMastaIteHab

    Trusted Prestigious

    Song is great, I don’t necessarily care what tempo a Menz song is as long as Greg is doing his little shouty voice and there’s plenty of that here.
     
  7. killermikestoklasa

    Newbie

    I feel like the band has been treading water since ATP. It was fine before because the songwriting was stronger. But now everything just sounds meh.

    still the best live band though.
     
    Cameron likes this.
  8. m32137

    Trusted

    Chcurry182 and screwflanders like this.
  9. Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

    Went with the everything splatter.
     
  10. Chcurry182

    Trusted Supporter

  11. m32137

    Trusted

    Same. Annoyed the Patreon discount code didn't work, but whatever.
     
  12. imthegrimace

    Beat em off, Bucs! Supporter

    Both songs are very by the numbers menzingers
     
    Transient_Hymn and onionbubs like this.
  13. onionbubs

    Trusted

    that literally is when you were young at the start lmao wow

    i know its just power chords, but like, cmon menzos
     
    fredwordsmith and tonyvalentine like this.
  14. swboyd

    are we still lucky to be here? Prestigious

    My sentiments exactly minus the negativity. The last two albums just didn't hit the same for me. This is my favorite song of theirs on first listen since After the Party so I'm here for more stuff in this vein as opposed to Nobody's Heroes.
     
  15. onionbubs

    Trusted

    i havent liked much of their output this decade, these songs included, but i am pretty happy for them reading that interview. they are good dudes
     
  16. VanderlyleCrybaby

    Regular Supporter

    This is true but weirdly they are one of the few artists that I don't mind kind of sounding the same-ish over the course of time. Idk they're great at the particular thing they do and I love that they give us exactly what we expect from a Menzingers song. Someone asked my opinion recently about Nobody's Heroes and I basically said "it's great, it sounds like the Menzingers" lol
     
  17. scottlechowicz

    Trusted Supporter

    I hold Some of It Was True in extremely high regard.

    So I’m looking forward to this. I got the rust colored variant
     
    dpatrick23, Paulms85 and Chcurry182 like this.
  18. 333 GANG

    Trusted Supporter

    I like both songs more than 2/3 of the last record (good, but lower tier menz for me) so I’m pretty excited for this one.
     
    AP_Punk likes this.
  19. abear182

    Regular

    Stoked for some new Menzos
     
  20. OhTheWater

    Let it run Supporter

    I came in here to defend some of the last record but checked the tracklist and don’t remember any of these songs lol. I meant to defend a song or two off of Hello Exile. It is crazy that I have not really enjoyed a Menzos record in almost a decade.
     
  21. Maybe won’t mean much to the thread cause I liked the last two albums too … but this one’s good. Fun summer vibe, kinda sitting between the last two in style. No complaints at all from my end.
     
  22. scottlechowicz

    Trusted Supporter

    Good enough for me!
     
  23. Contender

    Goodness is Nowhere Supporter

    Very into this song.
     
    333 GANG and dqwinny like this.
  24. mattfreaksmeout

    Trusted Supporter

    The last one didn’t really land for me except a few songs, but I do love Hello Exile and enjoy the new singles enough (slightly partial to today’s) so I’m pretty excited for this
     
  25. Zachary Dresch

    Trusted Supporter

    I didn't love the last album, but I love Will Yip's production with them, and this time it sounds more like the production of ATP with a little more maturity so I'm all for it.
     
    twisterman2006 likes this.