The Menzingers - Everything I Ever Saw (July 17, 2026) • Page 3

Excited to hear what's next for them.

 

new song rules

 

part of it reminds me of intro to The Killers "When You Were Young" which rocks

 

Always down for new menzingers

 

I've been overly harsh on them for the last two albums but I actually really like this new song. Here is to hoping I can reignite my love for their stuff. They're such good dudes, I hate having felt as negatively as I have about their recent output.

 

Meh

 

Very good song

 

It’s a little insane how this is just When We Were Young by The Killers and similar to Rodent for the verse. Awesome song though.

 

Prefer Nobody's Heroes over this. It's alright.

 

I’m enjoying “Chance Encounters” a lot. Pretty stoked for this album now!

 

“You sit there in your heartache…”

 

The 2 songs are fine. They haven't grabbed me like the lead-off singles from a new Menzingers album usually do.

 

Good song. Feel like this one really balances out their older "energy" with their newer sound

 

Strong Mr. Brightside vibes in the intro.

I love it.

 

It's pretty much 'When We Were Young' like someone said above

 

there it is. I knew something wasn’t right when I was typing that haha. Got the band right though!

 

Making sure I am not missing anything but no pre-orders or anything yet right?

 

2 for 2 in the 'meh' category

 

Love Chance Encounters. Have grown on Nobody's Heroes

 

Like them both but agreed not blown away by either.

 

Love this and nobody’s heroes I think this is shaping up to be better than the last album

 

https://www.epitaph.com/products/everything-i-ever-saw-lp-sunburst-splash

https://www.epitaph.com/products/everything-i-ever-saw-lp-black

 

Kinda funny that my gf is also a big menzis fan and we recently talked about how she hasn't seen Truman Show.