The Menzingers - After the Party (February 3, 2017) Album • Page 81

awww this makes me sad :/

 

me 2

 

I will never get why people dislike Tom's songs, Burn After Writing and Sculptors and Vandals are two of this band's best.

 

Once the record has been around for a bit I can totally see The Bars being a huge singalong live. It's like an Irish drinking song.

 

they also happen to be the only tom songs that are on the same level as greg's (imo ofc), and greg sings like half of burn anyway

e: actually i take the first part of this back. sculptors is a good song but there are several that are better on otip

 

I've only really liked Greg songs apparently then lol. I have always had a hard time telling which singer is which, but clearly I prefer Greg's writing style.

 

I firmly believe Tom and Greg are equal but that's just me

 

I just like it all and never really divided them until reading these forums lol

 

Imo they both really stepped it up in this album, but I'll still take Greg over Tom any day of the week

 

Dancing around the kitchen with my girlfriend to this album last night, particularly Charlie's Army, was pretty awesome.

 

Chamberlain Waits still has the best Tom songs imo but ATP is already second in terms of their parity w/ Greg songs.

 

They both sing on Tasker Morris Station as well

 

So glad someone actually did this! Whether or not you saw my post earlier does not matter to me. I still feel like I played a part.

 

I definitely saw your post earlier and had it in mind!

 

Sooo cool! Love this band, love this thread.

Currently spinning their catalog in order on my drive to Chicago. You forget how well the old songs hold up sometimes.

 

I'm in love with all but 3 songs and I'm sure I will come around to them. Can't stop wanting to listen.

 

I think I'm on board with the title track now, but I still don't like Thick as Thieves much. That's the only song I don't love at this point. Haven't had an album dominate my listening this much in years.

 

greg is green day and tom is blink 182

 

Funny how this band works. My friend that checked out the album and band for the first time only loved Thick As Thieves at first. He's coming around to the rest now.

 

any idea who wrote each song on Lesson?

 

Thick as Thieves rules. Anything that has an 80s sound gets my seal of approval

 

The chorus is just dull imo

 

Tom is awesome, Greg is awesome, and there's a damn good chance their best work is still ahead of them.

 

I've been told there's no going home, no room for you and me, no empty seats in eternityyyyyy

 

Yes. There are some really cool guitar tones in that song.