The Mandalorian (Disney+) TV Show • Page 201

Discussion in 'Entertainment Forum' started by Joe, Oct 4, 2018.

  1. Michael Belt

    metadata incarnate Supporter

    the joke of it all is that Favreau has said his S4 scripts are an entirely different thing, more tied to Ahsoka S2/Thrawn that anything else. Disney pushed for this not only to get a Star Wars movie back in theaters (given the development backlog), but because they likely had gaps in their release schedule due to the strikes.

    i get maybe alienating casual viewers by just translating a higher-stakes, lore-heavy, interconnected season of television into a movie, so i get why the story is the way that it is (i'm seeing it tomorrow, so idk much about it beyond what's been said here). it's just funny that on top of that, they supposedly didn't do anything of high importance for these characters beyond sending them off on a largely-disconnected adventure, and that this could probably be the end of that story if it doesn't do well. you can still do a one-off but give it stakes or character development, and everything i'm hearing makes it sound like there's none. but hey, anything to make money, i guess.

    i don't really have high expectations for most SW projects since they vary so much in tone, quality, and audience, so i'm still expecting to have a decent time tomorrow, but i wouldn't be surprised if i just don't revisit this much after.
     
    JoshIsMediocre likes this.
  2. tvck

    the price of living, the art of suffering Prestigious

    as someone who didn't watch season 3 and remembers very little of season 1 and 2, it absolutely does not feel like you need to know anything really going in other than who the 2 mains are lol
     
  3. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    See every role she's taken in the last 15 years. She's definitely in the "cut a paycheck" phase of her career.
     
    Azz likes this.
  4. JoshIsMediocre

    the world is quiet here Supporter

    [​IMG]
     
    Zilla, coleslawed, Greg and 4 others like this.
  5. oakhurst

    Trusted Supporter

    SteveLikesMusic likes this.
  6. popdisaster00

    That fortune smiles on me Moderator

    Well Disney really knows how to make us sick of things don't they
     
    JoshIsMediocre likes this.
  7. Dodge725

    Trusted

    There’s a difference between low stakes adventure that doesn’t tie into anything larger and having no real depth or substance. Thinking about it more, that’s really my biggest issue with this movie. It’s more of a series of action scenes tied together with the bare minimum for plot and no character development. I’m a big proponent of the Lucas “Star Wars is for 12 years olds” idea because they’re meant to be a way to teach lessons and inspire that age group (while also doing the same for those who are older) and this movie is missing that completely. It’s a fun watch, but doesn’t feel very Star Wars.
     
  8. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    I guess I'll see this. Gonna make it a Mandalorian Monday.
     
  9. JoshIsMediocre

    the world is quiet here Supporter

    Remember all those fallen Mandalorians
     
    Taketimeandfind likes this.
  10. FlayedManOfSF

    Trusted

    I'm not sure I agree with the sentiment that this was like the Mario movie. There was cohesive plot of Mando doing the right thing despite being urged on all sides to take shortcuts. This meant standing up for Rotta even though the New Republic wanted to just hand him off to die at the hands of the Hutts.
    Don't get me wrong, I didn't think it was a great movie at all. I probably give it a 6.5/10 and am currently unsure if I'll see it again unless someone invites me to see it again but it's nowhere near the nonsense of the Mario movie. There's clear motivations for all characters, however shallow those motivations may be.
     
  11. FlayedManOfSF

    Trusted

    Oh I forgot to mention the best part of the movie: the soundtrack. Absolutely love the Shakari theme. Some real bangers on here.
     
    coleslawed and WanderingSquall like this.
  12. justin.

    請叫我賴總統 Supporter

    I dozed off maybe 5 or 6 times during this

    The dragon/lizard guy on his rocking chair was cool, I guess
     
  13. Taketimeandfind

    Prestigious Prestigious

    How did they not release this Fathers Day weekend?

    This wasn’t bad. Just not a whole lot going on. The action was decent. Felt very 90s action movie, especially at the beginning. If anything was too long, especially the Grogu part. Kinda weird that it didn’t tie into the main story at all but that can also be a pro I suppose. It kind of made me want to rewatch Solo. I’m not mad that it exists. Definitely had a story but they didn’t beat you over the head with it. Hope we get a conclusion to the main story though
     
  14. Michael Belt

    metadata incarnate Supporter

    this was decent. a fun time, but probably the least consequential Star Wars has been for a while aside from Grogu getting to do stuff on his own and Rotta being the last surviving Hutt, unless i'm mistaken on that latter part. my partner loved it.
     
  15. "least consequential" after the decade they've had tells me about all i need to know about this
     
  16. Michael Belt May 23, 2026
    (Last edited: May 23, 2026)
    Michael Belt

    metadata incarnate Supporter

    it's funny to think how low on people's radar this is and how much the marketing sucked for this movie. before we saw it, we stopped by an outlet mall to look for new shoes. i wore my Rogue One shirt to the movie today (just a shirt with the film's logo i got at Disney World a decade ago that had its sales money go to charity), and the guy at the front of the store asked if it was my favorite SW movie (it is), and when i said we were headed to go see the new film, he didn't even know one was coming out.
     
    phaynes12 and JoshIsMediocre like this.
  17. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    I remember when Star Wars was an event. Now it's not even a blip.
     
    justin. and phaynes12 like this.
  18. i do think starfighter will naturally be bigger than this but yeah it feels like the mcu, just flop sweat everywhere
     
  19. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    phaynes12 likes this.
  20. Serh

    Prestigious Prestigious

    recent mcu is certainly not all (or even mostly) dogshit if you paid actual attention. that's why i fear worse for disney star wars, i don't see anything on par w/ thunderbots, shang-chi or especially gotg3 on the horizon
     
    Penlab likes this.
  21. Serh

    Prestigious Prestigious

    anyway, i'll most likely never think of this movie again. sucks that the worst star war may still be ahead of us
     
  22. Taketimeandfind

    Prestigious Prestigious

    This would have been better as a palate cleanser between two flagship movies. Can’t believe Scorsese was in this
     
    coleslawed likes this.
  23. Dodge725

    Trusted

    I’m ok with the idea that the worst SW may be ahead of us if it means they at least take some big swings. If they try new things that don’t quite work or don’t speak to me, but resonate with others, then I’m alright with that. I just don’t want the franchise to become safe and stagnant.
     
    Michael Belt likes this.
  24. Penlab

    Prestigious Supporter

    Sorry, capitalism dictates we'll get one focus tested adventure every three to four years until expiration.
     
    coleslawed likes this.
  25. Michael Belt

    metadata incarnate Supporter

    the risk-taking is a huge part of it, and God, i hope they take some risks. it's why i ultimately had a great time with The Acolyte despite its flawed pacing and somewhat wooden acting. it felt different and exciting at its best.