The Hotelier - Goodness (May 27, 2016) Album • Page 202

You In This Light is a jam and I love it, I'm in disbelief that it could be on anyone's lower end.
Also yeah this is really not the same album if you make any sort of subtractions -- can't take off the interludes. I think I remember people wanting to replace Goodness Pt 2 with Pt 1 or replacing new Settle the Scar with the old one and am balking very hard at the idea of that once again. It's like that alternate Devil and God track list to me, just all kinds of fucked. It's not that serious, but can't account for yr feelings hah

 

You In This Light reminds me of Clarity JEW :O

 

I don't really get that from it. It's a good little rock jam, it's a great song . It's just my least favorite of the other songs.

 

Fear of Good is incredible and if it's an interlude it's the best interlude I've ever heard

 

but the mewithoutYou spider songs exist?

 

Oh damn touché

 

Also coordinate track #2 exists

 

Great post Kennedy

 

When I said Piano Player was my least favorite, I forgot that You In This Light existed. I actively dislike that song.

Also, all the interludes (including Fear of Good) are fantastic in my book.

 

never before have i encountered such negativity on the internet towards You In This Light. the experience has left me shook

 

i mean, I love the song it just isnt my favorite. Its probably my least favorite song from Home and Goodness not counting Housebroken (although viewing Housebroken as an anti-cop song has elevated it in my eyes but I still totally acknowledge its problematic interpretations and fully support the band for taking it out of setlists and addressing the issues with it).

 

Barring lyrics, housebroken just isn't a great song

You know what is though? You in This Light

 

You in this light is one of their most original songs imo

 

I feel completely opposite. Lyrics aside, the music of Housebroken is very good and much better than YITL

 

Name a song that follows the structure or even sounds like you in this light from this scene. The super high vocals over very 90s sounding guitar chords which are also really 4thy and susy which is cool. I don't know how you could say it doesn't at least sound original

 

Just want to add it's completely cool that you don't like it; but to say it's the opposite of original is to say the songs generic and I just can't agree with that lol

 

ewww

 

I never said that...

 

Oh, I see. I was responding to Zac's post, not the one about its originality.

 

I just realized that you were responding to the post before mine even though yours was right after mine! Ha

 

I love the melodies in Housebroken. YITL is very dull to me.

 

Yeah, that's what I get for not quoting. Oops.

 

And what I get for not reading deeper into context clues ha. It's all good

 

Ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

 

Never said it wasn't great!