The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 57

I feel like this is one of the more predictable finals. Do this many people dislike Six Feet Under? I thought it was pretty much a given that was one of the fan favorites. And people really like Future Hearts, so it's not really crazy that the best song from that is still here. I don't think anything from Dirty Work or PUoSU ever stood a chance, and I don't think there's enough consensus about what the best songs on LYR are for a song from that to take it. The only real surprise is that Weightless isn't up here, but it's just the way the voting works.

 

To be fair, I was disappointed with the outcome of pretty much every round but Future Hearts

 

Weightless

I would've voted for weightless had I known this was the final round lol

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

6ft

 

Cinderblock Garden

That was somewhat of a difficult decision for me!

 

Six Feet is fine, but it doesn’t belong anywhere near a final round for this band imo. I’m sjrprised Weightless didn’t beat it.

As far as individual album rounds, I was only really happy with the outcomes for NP and LYR.

 

CURRENT TOTALS

Cinderblock Garden: 11
Six Feet Under the Stars: 11

 

Six Feet Under the Stars

 

This is nail-biting.

 

I would have been totally cool with Last young renegade winning this but cinderblock garden is such a weak song

also tidal waves is one of catchiest songs they've written not sure how that didn't win FH

(just gonna casually drop opinions here, sry)

 

actually I think Last Young Renegade and Damned if I Do Ya are tied for their "best" songs

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

Damned, Last, and Cinderblock are all the best songs on their respective albums

Actually, Missing You beats Cinderblock for me, but they’re close enough

 

Will agree with this!

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

Six Feet

 

Good Times should have made it to the final

 

lol still tied. Has everyone voted?

 

This is intense!

 

I feel like Weightless wouldve won had it beat out Six Feet too which is interesting

 

CURRENT TOTALS

Cinderblock Garden: 13
Six Feet Under the Stars: 13

A user that hasn't been voting for a long time has reappeared.

Still 4,5 hours remaining. Anything can happen.

 

“Last Young Renegade” should have won, IMO.

 

END OF FINALE

Cinderblock Garden: 13
Six Feet Under the Stars: 13 (14) tie-break

It's official, the ultimate ATL champion is:
SIX FEET UNDER THE STARS

On behalf of the song I'd like to thank everyone who voted for it, ever since the album round-up.

Also, thanks to everyone who participated in this bracket. I've had a lot of fun running it.

Feel free to continue discussions in this thread, it might help on the post-bracket blues.

 

Nice