The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 46

Caroline
Toxic Valentine

 

I think we know who won. NEXT ROUND!!!

 

End of ROUND 1

There's hardly any doubt which songs are the winners.

Caroline: 11
Alejandro (Lady Gaga cover): 1
----------
Toxic Valentine: 10
Time to Break Up (blink-182 cover): 2

ROUND 2:
2a) Caroline vs. Fool’s Holiday
2b) Take Cover vs. Painting Flowers
2c) Toxic Valentine vs. Longview (Green Day cover)
2d) Umbrella (Rihanna cover) vs. True Colors (Cyndi Lauper cover)

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

Painting Flowers is the best song and 100% deserves to win this.

 

Fool's Holiday
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

 

Caroline
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Um-ber-ella

 

I was actually present at a show in Jersey where they played the Umbrella cover for what they said was either the first time or one of the first times (can't remember what Alex said). This was, like, immediately after SWIR came out. It wasn't even done, it was just an early version with just the first verse and chorus that they were messing around with, like about a year before Punk Goes Crunk even came out. That was fun.

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers (even though I love Take Cover and hate voting against it this early)
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

 

Fool
Take
Toxic
True

 

Caroline
Painting flowers
Toxic valentine
True colours

 

Fool's Holiday
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

Painting Flowers best win this one

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers
Longview (Green Day cover)
True Colors (Cyndi Lauper cover)

 

Caroline
Painting Flowers
Toxic Valentine
Umbrella

 

gonna sit this one out, haven't heard half of these

 

Just donkey vote like me

2a) Fool’s Holiday
2b) Painting Flowers
2c) Toxic Valentine
2d) Umbrella (Rihanna cover)

 

I’d honestly take True Colors over almost any of their other B-sides/covers, so I’m surprised it’s getting beaten so badly.

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers
Longview (Green Day cover)
Umbrella (Rihanna cover)

 

I suspect no one has actually heard True Colors, they just pick Umbrella because that's the one they've heard.

 

Boo.

 

Yeah I didn’t know it exists. So I went the widely heard umbrella. Keen to hear the lauper classic

 

Fool’s Holiday
Painting Flowers
Longview (Green Day cover)
True Colors (Cyndi Lauper cover)

That True Colors cover is one of my favorites of theirs!

 

End of ROUND 2

The matches aren't really that close, and there are a lot of inactive users this round.

Caroline: 3 (RIP)
Fool’s Holiday: 10
----------
Take Cover: 1 (RIP)
Painting Flowers: 12
----------
Toxic Valentine: 10
Longview (Green Day cover): 3 (RIP)
----------
Umbrella (Rihanna cover): 9
True Colors (Cyndi Lauper cover): 4 (RIP) this sucks. It's their best cover.

ROUND 3:
3a) Fool’s Holiday vs. Painting Flowers
3b) Toxic Valentine vs. Umbrella (Rihanna cover)

 

Fool's Holiday
Toxic Valentine

 

Painting flowers
Umbrella