Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 4

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by BlackwingE, Feb 2, 2018.

  1. BlackwingE Feb 6, 2018
    (Last edited: Feb 6, 2018)
    BlackwingE

    Trusted

    CURRENTLY
    Hit the Lights (Tribute to a Night I’ll Never Forget): 4
    Memories That Fade Like Photographs: 6

    (!) Just a short announcement: The Party Scene and Put Up or Shut Up will be put in the same round-up, as the latter has only two songs that aren't on the album. I actually regret not doing all songs before So Wrong, It's Right together. I know a lot of people look forward to being done with the band's oldest stuff.
     
    bachna84 likes this.
  2. mattfreaksmeout

    Trusted Supporter

    Hit the Lights (Tribute to A Night I'll Never Forget)
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  3. jess

    Newbie

    Hit The Lights
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  4. henry boyd

    Newbie

    thanks
     
  5. BlackwingE

    Trusted

    CURRENTLY
    Hit the Lights (Tribute to a Night I’ll Never Forget): 6
    Memories That Fade Like Photographs: 6

    1 hour to go...
     
  6. BlackwingE

    Trusted

    ROUND 2 IS OVER
    The round-up for The Three Words to Remember in Dealing with the End EP has ended.

    TOTALS
    Hit the Lights (Tribute to a Night I’ll Never Forget): 6
    Memories That Fade Like Photographs: 6

    It’s a TIE! And I will have to break it with a final vote.

    And the winner is:
    Hit the Lights (Tribute to a Night I’ll Never Forget)

    Moving on...

    ALL TIME LOW BRACKET - ROUND-UP #2
    The Party Scene / Put Up or Shut Up EP

    ROUND 1:
    1a) Circles vs. Break Out! Break Out!
    1b) Interlude vs. Prelude (kinda funny match-up)
    1c) The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler vs. Lullabies
    1d) We Say Summer vs. Sticks, Stones and Techno
    1e) Coffee Shop Soundtrack vs. The Party Scene
    1f) I Can’t Do the One-Two Step vs. Jasey Rae
    1g) Running from Lions vs. Noel
    ----------
    ROUND 2:
    2a) Winner of 1a vs. Hometown Heroes; National Nobodies
    2b) Winner of 1b vs. Winner of 1c
    2c) Winner of 1d vs. Winner of 1e
    2d) Winner of 1f vs. Winner of 1g

    And… begin!
     
    bachna84 likes this.
  7. allblueocean

    Every outcome's such a comedown

    a) Break Out! Break Out!
    b) Interlude
    c) The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    d) We Say Summer
    e) Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    f) Jasey Rae
    g) Running from Lions
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  8. cricketandclover

    Things have changed.

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Interlude
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  9. Break Out! Break Out!
    Prelude
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    We Say Summer
    The Party Scene
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  10. Spenny

    Regular

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Interlude
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  11. Anthony_ Feb 7, 2018
    (Last edited: Feb 14, 2018)
    Anthony_

    A (Cancelled) Dork Prestigious

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Prelude
    Lullabies
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions

    Album Ranking
    Running From Lions
    Lullabies
    Jasey Rae
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Hustler
    Break Out
    The Party Scene
    Circles
    Hometown Heroes; National Nobodies
    We Say Summer
    Noel
    One-Two Step
    Prelude
    Interlude
    Sticks, Stones, and Techno
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  12. Micool1

    Trusted Supporter

    Break Out
    Interlude
    Lullabies
    We Say Summer
    Party Scene
    Jasey Rae
    Running From Lions

    #TeamInterlude
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  13. BlackwingE

    Trusted

    The Party Scene needs more votes.

    Also, GO #TeamInterlude !!
     
  14. JaytotheGee

    Trusted Prestigious

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Interlude
    Lullabies
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  15. jjnunn118

    Signal Vs. Noise Prestigious

    Circles
    Interlude
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running from Lions


    Let's go #TeamCircles
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  16. FTank

    Trusted Prestigious

    Circles
    Interlude
    Lullabies
    We Say Summer
    Coffee
    Jasey
    Noel
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  17. Rob Hughes

    I wish you'd love me for life

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Prelude
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    I Can’t Do the One-Two Step
    Noel
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  18. Rob Hughes

    I wish you'd love me for life

    #TeamOneTwoStep
     
  19. TEGCRocco

    Cyclops Stan

    Circles
    Interlude
    Lullabies (That one is straight up unfair. My two favorites from the pre-SWIR era by a significant margin)
    Sticks, Stones and Techno (just so it isn't a shutout)
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Noel
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  20. Jasey Rae is debatably my favorite song ever written so there was no contest there.
     
  21. bachna84

    we are nothing more than mannequins Prestigious

    Break Out! Break Out!
    Interlude
    Lullabies
    We Say Summer
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack
    Jasey Rae
    Running From Lions

    It’s too bad that either Coffee Shop Soundtrack or The Party Scene will be eliminated while Interlude or Prelude advance, but that’s how brackets work ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
     
    BlackwingE likes this.
  22. Anthony_

    A (Cancelled) Dork Prestigious

    When you assign the brackets randomly, it is at least. If the songs were seeded that wouldn't be the case.
     
    bachna84 and BlackwingE like this.
  23. mattfreaksmeout

    Trusted Supporter

    All these songs, especially the Put Up or Shut Up ones make me feel a way. They might be the first songs where I felt like they were truly mine, in that sense that I had discovered them myself and they weren't a huge band or anything. Look at me getting all emotional, this band means a lot to me.

    Circles
    Interlude
    Lullabies
    Sticks, Stones, and Techno
    The Party Scene
    Jasey Rae
    Running From Lions


    Because I know everyone definitely cares about my thought process:
    Circles: They played it the first time I saw them, and I didn't even grasp at the time what a rare occurrence it was.
    Lullabies: This one was brutal - probably my two favorites on PUoSU. I had Straight Up Hustler written down, but then I listened to both and Lullabies is such a gut punch of a song. I had a ton of summer nights listening to that in my basement feeling ~deep~. I'll give it Lullabies based on the backstory of the song.
    Sticks, Stones, and Techno: I've always really loved this song honestly. I have no idea why but I jammed it for a whole summer back in the day.
    Running From Lions: Well this one is kind of hard, because I'm pretty sure I listened to the wrong version of Running From Lions for years and years - I had an acoustic version that basically stayed like the intro to the song for the whole thing - and that's the Running From Lions I'm voting for, but I like Noel more than the Running From Lions full band version that I think is the real version? TL;DR I'm voting for Running From Lions, but in my head it's for the acoustic version.
     
    allblueocean and BlackwingE like this.
  24. BlackwingE

    Trusted

    CURRENTLY

    Circles: 4
    Break Out! Break Out!: 9
    ----------
    Interlude: 10
    Prelude: 3
    ----------
    The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler: 6
    Lullabies: 7
    ----------
    We Say Summer: 11
    Sticks, Stones and Techno: 2
    ----------
    Coffee Shop Soundtrack: 10
    The Party Scene: 3
    ----------
    I Can’t Do the One-Two Step: 1
    Jasey Rae: 12
    ----------
    Running from Lions:10
    Noel: 3

    This could be decided right now if it wasn't for the close match between The Girl’s a Straight-Up Hustler and Lullabies, haha.
     
    allblueocean likes this.
  25. bachna84

    we are nothing more than mannequins Prestigious

    Oh, I know. Random brackets are probably the way to go though since the seeding would be pretty subjective.