The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 39

Are you talking about the Anberlin bracket? In that case, didn't Dismantle. Repair. beat (*Fin) both times?

 

Dirty Laundry
Last Young Renegade
Good Times
Dark Side of Your Room (Best song vs worst song, so easy)

Also, YES.

 

Dirty Laundry
Last Young Renegade (love GC though)
Good Times
Dark Side of Your Room

 

Nah, I'm talking about Silverstein. Call It Karma beat Smile in Your Sleep for the album, but Smile won the wild card and ended up winning the whole thing.

 

Well, here we go. I ranked all the songs from SWIR to present, hope I didn’t forget anything. This was super difficult.

Missing You
Cinderblock Garden
Last Young Renegade
Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don’t)
Guts
Afterglow
Good Times
Tidal Waves
Dirty Laundry
Weightless
Break Your Little Heart
Stella
Dark Side of Your Room
Do You Want Me (Dead?)
Don’t You Go
Somewhere in Neverland
Poppin’ Champagne
How the Story Ends
Drugs & Candy
Ground Control
A Daydream Away
Outlines
Just the Way I’m Not
Satellite
Paint You Wings
Bottle and a Beat
Six Feet Under the Stars
Lost in Stereo
Poison
For Baltimore
That Girl
Heroes
Keep the Change, You Filthy Animal
The Reckless and the Brave
Hello, Brooklyn
Bail Me Out
The Edge of Tonight
Runaways
Old Scars/Future Hearts
Shameless
Chemistry
Dear Maria, Count Me In
Too Much
Walls
Merry Christmas, Kiss My Ass
Return the Favor
The Irony of Choking on a Lifesaver
If These Sheets Were States
A Party Song (The Walk of Shame)
A Love Like War
Oh, Calamity!
Kids in the Dark
Thanks to You
Something’s Gotta Give
Nice2KnoU
Nightmares
Vegas
Kicking and Screaming
Life of the Party
So Long, and Thanks for All the Booze
Let It Roll
Me Without You (All I Ever Wanted)
So Long, Soldier
Sick Little Games
To Live and Let Go
The Beach
Take Cover
Forget About It
No Idea
Therapy
Holly (Would You Turn Me On?)
This Is How We Do
Toxic Valentine
Remembering Sunday
Painting Flowers
Caroline
Bad Enough for You
My Only One
Backseat Serenade
Under a Paper Moon
Come One, Come All
Stay Awake (Dreams Only Last for a Night)
Canals
Vampire Shift
I Feel Like Dancin’
Get Down On Your Knees and Tell Me You...
Time-bomb
Your Bed
Dancing With a Wolf

 

I can't accept Dancing With a Wolf being placed as their worst song. And That Girl being anything but last.

 

Dancing With A Wolf is at the very least a top 10 ATL song no doubt about that

Nice2KnoU
Last Young Renegade
Afterglow
Dark Side of Your Room

Also, yes to the extra round

 

Dancing With a Wolf is so, so bad.

 

but That Girl... That Girl is such a bitch

see what i did there?

 

Why?

 

But That Girl is laughably bad.

 

Dirty Laundry
Ground Control
Afterglow
Life of the Party

 

Possibly the worst ATL song. Also, Bail me Out is criminally underrated.

 

I just don't understand your taste in this band.

 

Dirty Laundry
Last Young Renegade
Afterglow
Dark Side of Your Room

 

What am I supposed to do oh, oh
When she's so damn cold like twenty below
That girl, that girl she's such a bitch
But I tell myself I can handle it
You know I don't frequent the LBC
'Cause I'm a bit too pale to run that scene
The SoCal sun has grown on me and that girl, that girl
Started with a bottle of cheap champagne
Now she's got me hooked on her like good cocaine
She's so numb, miss Novocaine, that girl, that girl
So no kid, not tonight
You're not that good and I'm not that type
She's beautiful but she's cold as ice
And that keeps me hanging on
So what am I supposed to do oh, oh
When she's so damn cold like twenty below
That girl, that girl she's such a bitch
I tell myself I can handle it
But where am I supposed to go oh oh
When she throws me out and it's twenty below
That girl, that girl she's such a trick
But I can't lie I'm in love with it
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, that girl
Now she won't buy my sex appeal
Just an East Coast kid with a record deal
I play her song
She plays the field, that girl, that girl
Knock me on the street in the middle of winter
My frostbite heart says, "Try to forget her"
Missed that kiss but I'll always remember
That girl, that girl
So no kid, not tonight
You're not that cool, no you're not my type
She's beautiful but she's cold as ice
And I'm still hanging on
So what am I supposed to do oh oh
When she's so damn cold like twenty below
That girl, that girl she's such a bitch
I tell myself I can handle it
But where am I supposed to go oh oh
When she throws me out and it's twenty below
That girl that girl she's such a trick
But I can't lie I'm in love with it
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, that girl
Sit around waiting for the spark to fade
You can add another face to your pity parade
I can't believe it
I've never felt so cheated
Knocked me down, it was all pretend
Set me back up just to do it again
You say love's overrated
I say it's complicated
What am I supposed to do oh oh
When she's so damn cold like twenty below
That girl, that girl she's such a bitch
I tell myself I can handle it
But where am I supposed to go oh oh
When she throws me out and it's twenty below
That girl that girl she's such a trick
But I can't lie I'm in love with it
That girl, oh, oh, oh, oh
That girl, that girl,
That girl, that girl,
That girl

 

That Girl is at least a fun song musically. Every melody in Dancing is grating as hell, and it honestly doesn’t sound that different from something bands like Seether or Theory of a Deadman would write.

 

Joel Madz sounds great in it. They work well together

 

Nice2KnoU
Last Young Renegade
Good Times
Life of the Party

And yes to a wild card round!

 

That Girl sounds like a c-side from the less talented and out of date boyband ever

 

Nice2KnoU
Last Young Renegade
Good Times
Life Of The Party (fuck this one is brutal)

And yeah to the wildcard round

 

That Girl is hot garbage

 

Nice2KnoU
Last Young Renegade
Afterglow
Dark Side of Your Room

Yes to the wild card round.

 

1a). Dirty Laundry
1b) Last Young Renegade
1c) Good Times
1d) Life of the Party


Only listened to it again since my first few times since it came out
I think I like this less than Dirty Work. Except Life OTP and Drugs n Candy

 

CURRENT TOTALS

Nice2KnoU: 7
Dirty Laundry: 10
----------
Last Young Renegade: 13
Ground Control: 4
----------
Afterglow: 8
Good Times: 9
----------
Dark Side of Your Room: 12
Life of the Party: 5

Also, it looks to me like enough people want the extra wild card round, so I guess I'll run it after the B-side round.