Openers: Do You Want Me (Dead?) Last Young Renegade Weightless The Reckless and the Brave Prelude/The Party Scene This Is How We Do Satellite Closers: Old Scars/Future Hearts Heroes Therapy Poppin’ Champagne The Girl's a Straight-Up Hustler So Long, and Thanks for All the Booze Afterglow
Every All Time Low song (minus pre-PUOSU tracks except Circles & Noel) ranked Good Times Old Scars / Future Hearts Oh Calamity! The Edge Of Tonight Life Of The Party Jasey Rae Dark Side Of Your Room Lullabies Nightmares Missing You A Daydream Away Return The Favor Outlines Heroes Guts Cinderblock Garden So Long, And Thanks For All The Booze Nice2KnoU The Girl's A Straight-Up Hustler Remembering Sunday Too Much Walls Actors Sick Little Games Last Young Renegade Vegas Shameless Holly (Would You Turn Me On?) Somewhere In Neverland Drugs & Candy Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don't) For Baltimore Tidal Waves Paint You Wings Kids In The Dark The Reckless And The Brave If These Sheets Were States Dirty Laundry Satellite Stella Ground Control Therapy Coffee Shop Soundtrack Stay Awake (Dreams Only Last For A Night) Weightless Afterglow Do You Want Me (Dead?) Under A Paper Moon To Live And Let Go Thanks To You Six Feet Under The Stars How The Story Ends Time Bomb Backseat Serenade Bottle And A Beat Lost In Stereo Dear Maria, Count Me In Poppin' Champagne Dancing With A Wolf Your Bed Kicking & Screaming Dont You Go Vampire Shift Runaways Get Down On Your Knees And Tell Me You Love Me Forget About It Something's Gotta Give A Love Like War Canals Me Without You (All I Ever Wanted) The Irony Of Choking On A Lifesaver Circles Noel Break Your Little Heart Keep The Change, You Filthy Animal Poison My Only One No Idea Running From Lions A Party Song (The Walk Of Shame) Let It Roll Chemistry Bad Enough For You Just The Way I'm Not So Long, Soldier Merry Christmas, Kiss My Ass The Beach Hello Brooklyn This Is How We Do The Party Scene Break Out! Break Out! I Feel Like Dancin' Come One, Come All Bail Me Out That Girl It didn't actually click with me until making this how many songs they have
There's no way that I can rank all of their songs (I couldn't even do that with bands whose discography I've extensively listened to), but I'll do the openers and closers: Operners: Weightless Last Young Renegade Do You Want Me (Dead?) Satellite Reckless and the Brave Prelude/TPS This Is How We Do Closers: Old Scars/Future Hearts Oh, Calamity (I don't care that this is only the closer on the deluxe edition, it's fantastic) Afterglow Heroes Therapy Poppin' Champagne So Long and Thanks for all the Booze That Girl's a Straight Up Hustler
ATL songs that start with an S, ranked. because they're all good and also because fuck you Six Feet Under the Stars Sick Little Games Shameless Stella Satellite So Long, And Thanks For All The Booze Stay Awake So Long, Soldier Something's Gotta Give Somewhere in Neverland
I included the EP cause why not. Openers: Weightless Coffee Shop Soundtrack This Is How We Do The Reckless and the Brave Prelude/The Party Scene Do You Want Me (Dead?) Satellite Last Young Renegade Closers: Lullabies Poppin’ Champagne Therapy Old Scars/Future Hearts Heroes The Girl's a Straight-Up Hustler So Long, and Thanks for All the Booze Afterglow
End of the FINAL ROUND The winner got 12 of 23 votes. Cinderblock Garden: 10 (RIP) Old Scars/Future Hearts: 12 Moving on to Last Young Renegade ROUND 1: 1a) Nice2KnoU vs. Dirty Laundry 1b) Last Young Renegade vs. Ground Control 1c) Afterglow vs. Good Times 1d) Dark Side of Your Room vs. Life of the Party Upcoming ROUND 2: 2a) Winner of 1a vs. Vampire Shift 2b) Winner of 1b vs. Drugs & Candy 2c) Winner of 1c vs. Chemistry 2d) Winner of 1d vs. Nightmares IMPORTANT: Also, I was thinking about doing a wild card round before the big championship with all the winning songs. The wild card round includes all the runner up songs from each album, which means all the songs that lost the final rounds will have another chance to battle their way to the top. But, I will only run a wild card round if people want me to. Therefore, after voting for the songs in this first round, please vote YES or NO at the bottom of your post. Let's do this democratically. Begin!
Nice2KnoU Ground Control (fuck) Afterglow Life of the Party i think bonus songs should be in the first round, they're likely to go down first anyway also YES
Dirty Laundry Last Young Renegade Good Times Dark Side of Your Room As for the runner-up round, YES (if only because I have no idea how Cinderblock Garden lost that round).
Dirty Laundry (hardest match-up) Ground Control Afterglow Dark Side of Your Room (easiest match-up) Yes to bonus round! Are we also doing a b-sides round? Stuff like Toxic Valentine, Actors, Painting Flowers, Take Cover, etc.? And also what are Vampire Shift and Chemistry? Bonus songs from this album? I haven't heard those.
Nice2KnoU Last Young Renegade Afterglow (I'm not sure I'll ever understand the love for Good Times) Dark Side of Your Room
Dirty Laundry Ground Control Good Times (fuck that's hard) Dark Side of Your Room (also hard) The only other time I've seen a wild card round, the wild card ended up winning the whole thing, even beating the song that beat it in the first place. I vote YES. Also what the hell? I didn't know those two bonus tracks existed.
Yes, we're doing a b-sides round. But Actors is technically a demo, not a b-side, so I wasn't going to include it.