The Greatest Song of All Time (Low) - The ATL Bracket Bracket • Page 37

Cinderblock

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

This is the correct final round for this album. Anyway:

Old Scars/Future Hearts

 

Cinderblock Garden until I die. Top tier ATL song.

 

Cinderblock

 

Cinderblock

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

Cinderblock Garden

 

Old Scars

 

Old Scars

 

Old Scars/Future Hearts

Tough matchup! Either song would be a deserving winner.

 

My top 25:

1. Weightless
2. Cinderblock Garden
3. Six Feet Under The Stars
4. Coffee Shop Soundtrack
5. Do You Want Me (Dead?)
6. Holly (Would You Turn Me On?)
7. Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don't)
8. Remembering Sunday
9. Somewhere In Neverland
10. Tidal Waves
11. Vegas
12. Stella
13. Walls
14. A Party Song (The Walk Of Shame)
15. Old Scars / Future Hearts
16. Outline
17. Heroes
18. Dear Maria, Count Me In
19. Therapy
20. Too Much
21. The Beach
22. The Edge Of Tonight
23. Jasey Rae
24. Stay Awake (Dreams Only Last For A Night)
25. Actors

I guess this is what I'd consider top tier ATL. Kinda crazy they already have seven albums, but then again I'll turn 25 this year (damn).

Haven't listened to all of Last Young Renegade yet. From the half I heard, it is easily my least favorite record since The Party Scene, though. "Dirty Laundry" was an exception and, in time, it could even enter this top 25.

 

yup this is the only possible final

Old Scars cause its the best ATL closer

hate how they play it live though cause it's a step down and they just stand there like it isn't a fucking rocker

 

The best ATL closer is Afterglow

 

second best for sure

 

They're definitely the top two, with Poppin' Champagne in as the clear #3. Don't know which I'd put at #1 though.

 

cinderblock

 

Afterglow
Poppin’ Champagne
Heroes
Old Scars/Future Hearts
So Long, and Thanks for All the Booze
Therapy

I think that’s how I’d do it.

 

Afterglow
Poppin
Old Scars
Heroes
Therapy
So Long

Heroes and Therapy are pretty interchangeable though.

 

Old Scars

 

To me, they definitely have better openers than closers.

Last Young Renegade
Satellite
Weightless
Do You Want Me (Dead?)
The Reckless and the Brave
This is How We Do

 

Old Scars/Future Hearts
Afterglow
Poppin’ Champagne
Therapy
So Long, and Thanks for All the Booze
Heroes

Weightless
Last Young Renegade
Satellite
Do You Want Me (Dead?)
This is How We Do
The Reckless and the Brave

wow for being their best album Don't Panic sure has mediocre opener and closer songs

 

Afterglow is the perfect closer. Best opener is probably Do You Want Me (Dead?). They opened with it the first time I saw them and it was incredible.

 

Do You Want Me (Dead?)
Weightless
This Is How We Do
Satellite
Last Young Renegade
The Reckless and the Brave

That was really hard though like that makes it look like I don't like Last Young Renegade and The Reckless and the Brave at all, but that's just not the case.

 

This Is How We Do is the weakest opener by a mile, the rest are all very good. SWIR is their only album with a better closer than opener