The Gaslight Anthem Band • Page 59

In the sense of them making new music together, I think so too. In terms of them playing a show here and there together again, I'm open to thinking this is possible. I hope they do something next year for 10 Year Anniversary 59' Sound.

I'm just praying you don't have any more information than what's on the surface and what we already know :(

 

I thought The Horrible Crowes was him and Perkins? Either way, the songs and themes, and the overall mood of Elsie were obviously vastly different than on Painkillers. I love both, and as excited as I am for another Fallon solo record, I'd love another Elsie-esque album from him.

 

You left out a couple of matches. I wanna be able to count all your votes in before I close this down

 

She Loves You (8) vs. Stay Lucky (13)

Stay Vicious (13) vs. Stray Paper (8)

Sweet Morphine (10) vs. Teenage Rebellion (11)

The '59 Sound (9) vs. The Backseat (12)

The Diamond Street Church Choir (19) vs. The Navesink Banks (2)

Good morning all! The 2 middle matches are all still super close. I'm keeping this open for another 2 hours to see if we can get some more votes to trickle in. I appreciate you all taking part in this.

 

When I interviewed him last year, he basically said that he would love to do an Elsie Part 2 at some point, but that it would be under the Brian Fallon moniker and not the Horrible Crowes.

 

Stay Lucky (She Loves You could be the best of the B sides though)

Stay Vicious

Teenage Rebellion

The '59 Sound

The Diamond Street Church Choir (Navesink is underrated though)

 

I gotcha. Well that's cool that he's at least toying with that notion of another Elsie. I'm excited to see what he and Ted Hutt do with this next solo album

 

She Loves You (8) vs. Stay Lucky (14)

Stay Vicious (14) vs. Stray Paper (8)

Sweet Morphine (10) vs. Teenage Rebellion (12)

The '59 Sound (10) vs. The Backseat (12)

The Diamond Street Church Choir (20) vs. The Navesink Banks (2)

Those 2 middle matches are still too close to call, plus there are a few more votes I'm anticipating to come in, so I'll keep this open a little while longer.

 

Glad to see Stray Paper was somewhat close. Shoutout to the one other person who voted Navesink haha

 

Perkins definitely had an influence on it, but once I heard Brian’s production on Hustle Up Starlings, it became evident that he was the driver of that sound.

 

I think i would have enjoyed Underneath the Ground if it were on Elsie where it belongs

 

Stay Lucky

Stay Vicious

Sweet Morphine

The Backseat

The Diamond Street Church Choir

 

She Loves You
Stay Vicious
Teenage Rebellion
The Backseat
The Diamond Street Church Choir

 

She Loves You (9) vs. Stay Lucky (15)

Stay Vicious (16) vs. Stray Paper (8)

Sweet Morphine (11) vs. Teenage Rebellion (13)

The '59 Sound (10) vs. The Backseat (14)

The Diamond Street Church Choir (22) vs. The Navesink Banks (2)

 

Think we gotta call this round, some rounds are close but time to move on!

 

Okay, it seems the counts have stopped coming in. Thanks for your votes everyone! This means that...

Stay Lucky
Stay Vicious
Teenage Rebellion
The Backseat
and The Diamond Street Church Choir will advance to Round 2

HOWEVER we are still in Round 1. The last phase of matches will be:

The Patient Ferris Wheel vs. The Queen of Lower Chelsea

The Spirit of Jazz vs. Too Much Blood

Underneath the Ground vs. We Came to Dance

We Did It When We Were Young vs. We're Getting a Divorce, You Keep the Diner

Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis? vs. Wooderson

GO!!!

 

The Patient Ferris Wheel
The Spirit of Jazz
Underneath the Ground
We're Getting a Divorce, You Keep the Diner
Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis?

 

We did it you guys, good job. I don't need to lock the thread.

 

I forgot one. That's awesome. Thought it was Diner vs. Wooderson. Phew

 

Patient Ferris Wheel
Spirit of Jazz
We Came To Dance
Diner
Wooderson

 

The Patient Ferris Wheel
The Spirit of Jazz
We Came to Dance
We’re Getting a Divorce, You Keep the Diner
Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis?

 

Ferris Wheel (this one was so hard)
Jazz
Dance
Diner
Elvis

 

Ferris Wheel
Spirit
Dance
Diner
Wooderson

Diner v WDIWWWY was tough, but considering i have the words “stay hungry stay free and do the best you can”’ tattooed i think thats my choice haha

 

The Patient Ferris Wheel
The Spirit of Jazz
Underneath the Ground
We Did It When We Were Young
Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis

 

Patient Ferris Wheel
Spirit of the Jazz
We Came to Dance
When We Were Young
Elvis

That first matchup was harder than I originally thought it would be

Too Much Blood gets too much hate but Spirit of the Jazz is the better song

I enjoy Underneath the Ground but I think it would have been a better Horrible Crowes track

Looks like Diner is getting a lot of love but I have a stronger connection with WDIWWWY