This article has been imported from chorus.fm for discussion. All of the forum rules still apply. The latest Earworm video from Vox discusses the “fade out” in pop-songs and why it has fallen out of favor over the past few years. I remain not a fan. Expand - View Original
haha yeah I don't mind it either. I feel like every band should have at least one song that fades out!
In my opinion it depends. There are songs where fade outs work (one iconic example that comes to mind is Boston's "More Than a Feeling", love that fade out) and songs where it feels forced. I don't have an issue with it if it fits well with the song.
Fading out is a dangerous thing. There are a few songs that I do enjoy the fade out, like More Than A Feeling mentioned above - but whenever I hear a fade, it makes me wonder what it had sounded like if the artist actually wrote a closer for it. Would it have made the song better? Do we only like the fade out because it's what we heard first and are used to? The only thing we have close enough to gauge what it would sound like, would be hearing the performance of the song live. One of the ultimate fade outs that I think destroyed the song was Coheed and Cambria's Everything Evil. I don't know much about the band post-IKSSE3 because I lost interest, but I do remember hearing the Everything Evil demo for the first time and the explosive ending literally giving me chills and making the hair on my neck stand up. So needless to say when they released the SSTB album and the song had a fade out, I wanted to flip tables. It took away what I had absolutely loved so much about that song (still a great album though). So again, it's situations like that where had that demo not leaked, I wouldn't have heard the version that had a closing, thus I may have thought the fade out was a great idea. You never know.
Crossfade was the thing that used to drive me nuts. I remember when iTunes first came out and everyone loved crossfading their tracks. Thank goodness that trend went away too.
I have gone on many rants about the fade out. I just assume they couldn't figure out how to finish the song however unfair of me that may be!
One song fades out at the same time the next song playing starts to fade in. Like a dissolve between scenes in a movie.
honestly one of the worst things ever conceived when it comes to the playback of music. who came up with this!!!!!! It was easy to turn off but so bizarre that it existed