Did a quick search in the thread and no one has mentioned the Spooked podcast yet (hosted by the same guy from NPR's Snap Judgement). Got so into that show around last Halloween...the way they do it comes across as really authentic (and therefore creepy af sometimes). It's not all creepy stuff, some just straight up head-scratchers or interesting stories. Anyways, season 3 is coming out soon if anyone wants to get into it. This one is a good place to start that has one reeeeally creepy story and one that is actually kinda nice.