Last Hope (not even a question) Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore (interludes are definitely all losing, but I love this one and NT is my least favorite b-side) Daydreaming Proof (This was actually harder than expected because I love some of the lyrics in BA more, but Proof is a stronger song overall)
Last Hope Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore Daydreaming Be Alone -I cried the first time I ever listened to Last Hope. I think it's the strongest initial reaction I ever had to a song and still kills me until this day. -Went with Interlude over Native Tongue because I really like the whole concept of including the interludes, and I thought NT was pretty forgettable. -Daydreaming vs. Still Into You was my hardest match up here. I truly love Still Into You, but Daydreaming is just such a gorgeous song, so I had to give it the edge. -Be Alone is one of Paramore's most underrated songs, and Proof is one of the most overrated (probably my least favorite on the album), so that one was a no brainer.
Fast in My Car I love how weird this song is while still being such a straight up blast to listen to. It’s really representative to me of their sort of “loose” feel at the time while still being tighter than they’d ever been. Interlude: I’m Not Angry Anymore No big story here, I just don’t really care for Native Tongue Still Into You Really tough choice here, I love both of these songs. But man, what a perfect single this was for them! I love this guitar lines in the verses, and Hayley really coming into a different type of animated identity than she’d been know for in the past. Also the line about going to meet the mother and the drive back home afterward always pulls at my heartstrings Proof Couldn’t have been an easier choice here, IMO this is the album’s best track vs the album’s worst track (one of the worst in their discog if I’m being real). Man, the release to the chorus in Proof is so gratifying after those verses build you up. And not like this isn’t all over the record, but a stellar performance from Jeremy, especially in the bridge.
Last Hope Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore Daydreaming Proof This album is a crazy ride of so many of the bands best and worst moments
Fast in My Car Native Tongue Still Into You (These are two of my favorite songs on the album so I hate to vote against one of them in the first round, but this is one of my favorite overall Paramore songs) Be Alone
Fast in My Car Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore Still Into You Be Alone This is the album that made me a fan! I still remember the first time listening, It was an experience
I slept on this album for a long time. The only songs I knew were the singles. One day YouTube suggested I watch this performance After that I decided to give it another spin and realized I had made a huge mistake
Last Hope Interlude: I’m Not Angry Anymore Daydreaming Proof I remember showing this record to everybody whether they were for or indifferent about Paramore. Although this record is filled with more songs I don’t tend to revisit as much compared to the other records, this release felt like a rebirth. The tracks that hit fucking hit. Future, Daydreaming, Last Hope, Ain’t It Fun, and Part II still kill me.
Final scores: Fast in My Car - 8 Last Hope - 19 Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore - 14 Native Tongue - 13 Daydreaming - 14 Still Into You - 13 Proof - 19 Be Alone - 8 Round 2: Ain't It Fun Vs. Last Hope Anklebiters Vs. Escape Route Hate to See Your Heart Break Vs. Interlude: I'm Not Angry Anymore Part II Vs. Interlude: Holiday (One of Those) Crazy Girls Vs. Daydreaming Tell Me It's Okay Vs. Future Grow Up Vs. Proof Now Vs. Interlude: Moving On
Ain’t It Fun Anklebiters Hate To See Part II Daydreaming Future Proof Now Lots of matchups! The only one I was bummed to vote against was Grow Up, but realistically I wouldn’t want it to win the album anyway. Great track though!
Gutted that Still Into You got booted - especially by a clunker like Daydreaming but hey Last Hope Anklebiters Hate to See Your Heart Break Part II (One of Those) Crazy Girls Future Grow Up Now