-The Only Exception -All I Wanted -Ignorance -Careful I hate the Brick by Brick lost, but happy it was at least a close race and not a shut out.
Misguided Ghosts All I Wanted (also loved Hayley's voice in the chorus especially) Ignorance Careful (I really do love Turn It Off though and wouldn't be mad if that one somehow won)
Misguided Ghosts All I Wanted Ignorance Turn It Off That last choice as much as I adore Careful, Turn It Off just has it all for this band. A super catchy lead, soft pretty verses with an anthemic chorus, a bonkers Hayley performance in the bridge, heartbreaking lyrics, an extended instrumental outro — they really hit all the stops for what I wanted from Paramore at the time in a single song.
I made a mistake above, so here is what I voted for this round with the change. (Thanks @Groogz for catching that!).
Nah, I like their style. @Micool1 change my votes to: -Let The Flames Begin -Emergency -Brick by Boring Brick -Renegade
These are brutal match ups, god. Misguided Ghosts All I Wanted Playing God Turn it Off 17 year old me would pick Careful every time but Turn It Off is just so enduring for me.
I didn’t vote for Turn It Off because Careful is a top 5 Paramore song for me along with Brick By Boring Brick (*sobs*). That said, loving the attention it’s getting here. I think it’s their most underrated song.