Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

Taking One Discography to a Desert Island • Page 3

Discussion in 'Article Discussion' started by Melody Bot, Aug 2, 2017.

  1. SmithBerryCrunch

    Trusted Prestigious

    I think I'd have to pick Yellowcard.
  2. thatwasamoment


    Beatles seems like an obvious choice. You would never get bored with Prince's vast discog. Personally, I'd probably choose Against Me!
    Ken likes this.
  3. Steve_JustAGuy


    Stones because they're awesome and have (approximately) 23049857 albums. Maybe Zeppelin as my 2. The National would work well for the overwhelming sadness of my situation.
    Ken and CarpetElf like this.
  4. angrycandy

    it's not a good turn Prestigious

    The National or Young Thug
    Anthony Brooks likes this.
  5. Craig Manning

    @FurtherFromSky Moderator

    Amazon can send a drone.
  6. Chinesefood


    Clay Aiken
    Essie likes this.
  7. Larry David

    I'll see you again in 25 years Prestigious

    The Beatles
    Ken likes this.
  8. Tom Lee

    Tea Leaf and ⅓ of Hora Douse.

    It might get me super depressed, but I'd go with Elliott Smith.

    Potentially maybe Conor Oberst if it includes all of his bands and iterations. Kevin Devine is a good shout too!
    EarthShifts likes this.
  9. iCarly Rae Jepsen

    I want your stupid love Supporter

    Chris Prindle and Craig Manning like this.
  10. Transient_Hymn

    Keep the Rubber Side Down Supporter

    I think I'd go dear hunter.
    The color spectrum alone might get me through.

    Radiohead is my other pick
    BEsterley likes this.
  11. Fox83



    I like that we won't acknowledge Cherone. As it should be. As it should be.
    Steve_JustAGuy likes this.
  12. CMilliken


    Responded to your tweet with Jimmy Eat World but I could get by with some Weezer too. The Beatles as well.
  13. coleslawed

    Eat Pizza

    my gut reaction is Brand New, but then I realized I don't really listen to the first two albums except for a song or two each.

    Might go with Copeland for newer/sceneish bands.

    Pink Floyd or Zeppelin might win out in the long run, though.
  14. midnightxtaylor

    oh, you went fast to the midnight land

    Honestly, I think I'd have to go with JEW as well. I would say Circa Survive, but I think they carry too much weight emotionally for me to only listen to them. Andrew McMahon would also be a good choice if we're including all bands.
    ImAMetaphor likes this.
  15. disambigujason

    Formerly js977 Supporter

    Off the top of my head I may choose Thursday. Underoath are my favorite band but thursday has more diversity. If I worried about being too angry I may choose anberlin.
  16. fredwordsmith

    Regular Supporter

    Green Day
    Andrew McMahon, assuming you get full access to bands he's been in - I certainly wouldn't restrict Springsteen pickers to his solo stuff (no E Street). Same with Petty (no Heartbreakers).

    But the winner is Motion City Soundtrack. Even though Go is a lowlight, it's STILL a good record. And everything else is ACES. They're the band that's defined my transition from kid to adult life thus far. Plus, I could keep track of their records based on season - IATM for spring, CTTM for summer, EIIKM and GO for fall and MDL/PS for winter.
  17. cpm9288


    i would have to go with Ryan Adams since his music is pretty diverse album to album. Plus he has so many singles on top of his albums.
    Former Planets likes this.
  18. what


    Beach Boys
    Jason Tate likes this.
  19. tumbleweedterror

    music is all we got

    Tough choice but I think I'd have to say Paramore or Fall Out Boy. They both have decently sized and decently varied catalogs and they're two of my all time favorite bands.
    kielhauck likes this.
  20. Bryan Diem


    Hard pick between D.R.U.G.S. and Deftones.

    All jokes aside, Deftones or bust. So much to get into, different moods, and i don't even like Adrenaline.
    Turkeylegz likes this.
  21. Orla

    right on!

    Smashing Pumpkins would probably be mine, but it's kinda painful having to choose between them and Tegan & Sara
  22. Bryan Diem


    Meat Loaf is my second place though.
  23. foomanfat


    BEsterley likes this.
  24. Malatesta

    i may get better but we won't ever get well Prestigious

    Probably CSNY if for no reason other than i could never sign off never listening to Suite: Judy Blue Eyes again.
    Republic of Wolves, perhaps, for how consistently solid they are. He Is Legend for the diversity and fun.
  25. ComedownMachine

    Prestigious Prestigious

    It'd be a very tough decision between Radiohead and Kanye for me
    Ken likes this.