On a serious note I'd probably rank a top 10 like this (in no particular order): Miami Timberwolves at New Jersey Number Five with a Bullet 180 By Summer I am Fred Astaire Brooklyn El Paso This Is All Now Bonus Mosh pt II There's No 'I" in Team TBH this is constantly changing and I don't think theres many songs within the first 3 albums I don't love.
Great Romances of the 20th Century You're So Last Summer A Decade Under The Influence This Photograph Is Proof Error: Operator Your Own Disaster Sink Into Me El Paso Flicker, Fade Holy Water
180 By Summer The Blue Channel Catholic Knees El Paso The Union I Felt It Too Theres No I In Team Everything Must Go Beat Up Car Bike Scene
I think when it's all said and done Homecoming will be in my top 10. That song is fucking great. I just can't place it above some of the other songs I've been listening to for 15 years.
Homecoming was the last song on Tidal Wave I got into. When I went in October and saw the Tidal Wave show and they played it is when it finally clicked for me
I wish I had a better experience at the Tidal Wave show I went to last year. The show was literally the day the album came out, so no one in the crowd knew the songs. People were being pretty rude and talking throughout the entire set around me. The album had only leaked the day before, so I barely knew any of the songs yet either. I would love to see the album in full now.
Mine was maybe a week or two after. It had more of a well received response, a lot even singing along but we had some rude people too. One guy kept shouting "Play your old shit this sucks!!!" Only 4-5 songs in, and since it was a small club they could clearly hear him. His girlfriend about smacked him and told him to stop being rude and he's just like "what it's true!!". He was the main rude one
That was about my reaction. And Nolan shot the door the evilest glare I've ever seen that man give lol
Dunno if I can define my top 10, but my top five is probably: 180 Holy Water You Know How I Do Phasers Decade
Hmmmm Cute Romances 180 Decade Slowdance My Blue Heaven Miami Carpathia Everything Must Go This Is All Now
Great Romances This Is All Now My Blue Heaven Best Places to be a Mom 180 by Summer Sad Savior Call Come Running Can You Feel That (Here I Am) Better Homes and Gardens Swing maybe? Or Your Own Disaster
not really thinking about it Slowdance You Know How I Do Bike Scene Cute Set Phasers To Stun Carpathia What's it Feel Like to be a Ghost? We Were Younger Then This is All Now 180
man, it's weird not seeing "flicker fade" on more peoples lists! that's a top 5 TBS song to me. it packs all the right punch. classic TBS tune.
Ghost Man On Third You Know How I Do Cute Without the 'E' (Cut from the Team) ...Slowdance On The Inside Set Phasers To Stun New American Classic Everything Must Go Best Places to Be a Mom Flicker, Fade Better Homes And Gardens
All I know is Call Me in the Morning is my absolute #1 fave. Damn do I love that song. New American Classic is prob my #2 and Better Home and Gardens is prob #3. Dunno if I could rank after that tbh
I think all their closers are great. I even think we've ranked them in the past. Mine were: A Slowdance I'll Let you Live Call Me in the Morning Nothing at All I'll Find A Way Head Club EMG (HOT TAKE)
I find their closers to be hit or miss. Call Me In the Morning, Slowdance, EMG are among their best but the rest I could leave. EMG Slowdance Call Me I'll Find A Way Headclub I'll Let You Live Nothing At All