Taking Back Sunday Band • Page 174

WYWTB
LN
TIDAL
HI
TAYF
S/T
NA

 

I mean honestly WYWTB > works too so everybody with that listed first gets a like!

 

So close but ill take it

 

Changes?

 

Id just put na on top basically haha

 

I’m ok with that. I don’t like the stretch of catholic thru carpathia but everything else is great.

 

Yeah I'd say Capital M-E and Catholic Knees are two of the weakest songs, aside from the title track. But yoooo Carpathia is so good

 

TAYF
Tidal
Happiness
WYWTB
Louder
NA
Self-titled

I realize today that New Again isn't last for me cause both those last two, I only love 4 or 5 songs but the great songs on NA are better than the s-t ones

 

probably my favorite of the 3 but if it didn't end on EMG i'd just skip the end of the record haha

 

WYWTB and New Again are basically tied for first for me at this point.

 

TAYF
Louder

Happiness
Self-titled

WYWTB
Tidal



NA

 

That middle section is kinda interchangeable for me, not sure how solid I am on the middles

 

WYWTB
TW
HI
LN
ST
TAYF




NA

where you want to be is so fucking good. Thought it was their most mature album up until tidal. Just a great early 20s album that never felt like it was being overly emotional and cliche like tayf did.

 

As much as I wanna say it isn't, WWTB is still my favorite tbs album.

 

I'm always a little disappointed with how little love s/t gets. I'm not sure where I would rank it now but it does have at least 5 songs I really love

Bottom two for me would be TAYF and LN

 

oy again with the rankings

 

Rankings.fm

 

The problem with S/T is that "Money" and "Since You're Gone" are offensively bad songs whose B-Side counterparts could've saved that album, and Eric Valentine's production kills everything. People like to shit on "Sad Savior" but like "Miami", the latter half of that song is pretty great.

 

WYWTB
TW
HI
LN
NA
TAYF
S/T

 

If we're gonna go album by album a list the worst song off each one, my ranking would go as follows:

The Blue Channel
The Union (pains me to say that because I actually love that song, but if there's a worst song on WYWTB, it's that one)
Up Against
Cut Me Up Jenny
Money
Like You Do
Homecoming (again, I actually like this song, but it's the weakest link on an otherwise great album)

 

Agree with all of this.

 

Sad Savior is top 3 on S/T

 

Also, to bring back up a topic discussed previously, "They Don't Have Any Friends" is a jam and I won't hear any different haha sure, it's not their best work lyrically, but musically it's incredible and Mark's drumming in the bridge is ace.

 

I pretty much agree with all of these except for WYWTB and TW I'd go:

Number 5 With A Bullet (for the record I still love this song. There's not a bad song on this record if you ask me)
In The Middle Of It All (a fine song, but very generic)

Honorable mention for me goes to It Doesn't Feel A Thing Like Falling for the self-titled. I know I'm in the minority here, but that song bores me to tears.

 

You just had a run of 4 remarkably (mostly) accurate/true posts and I just wanna commend you on that