This is my favorite single yet. I hear the Dirty Work comparison on it, it would fit in with Under A Paper Moon and Do You Want Me Dead pretty well
"Half Empty" might be my favorite ballad any pop-punk band has done. Reminds me of early 5SOS, but in the best way. Also "Everybody But You" is definitely the worst song on the album.
Everybody But You has to be the worst song this band has put out..I wouldn't mind the lyrics if the song was catchy but it's not
I think the only thing I don't like about EBY is Ben's part, the rest of that song gets stuck in my head whenever I hear it. Album is pretty good on first listen, Eventually is still one of my favorite things this band has done lately.
Maybe it caught me in the wrong mood but I found this pretty meh on first listen. I liked Living Proof a lot but I still feel like the band is an album or two behind in their progression. They’re clearly going further in the poppy direction here but in much smaller increments than it feels like they should be progressing especially given the amount of time between releases. And while the sonic direction definitely suits them, I just don’t think the songwriting itself is that strong here compared to what they’ve done in the past.