Silverstein Band • Page 25

The Artist is definitely one of my favourite Silverstein songs. Brendan compliments the band so well

 

The short songs finale should be I’ll Let You Live Vs Gasoline

 

The Artist is one of my least favorite on Rescue... It'll probably win.

 

The Artist is one of my favourites on Rescue but I'm all about In Memory Of from that album.

Smile in Your Sleep is bottom tier on DTW though.

 

It didn't age well that's for sure. But for nostalgic purposes alone, it'll get my vote. Shane screaming "you were gravely mistaken!" is a top 5 Silverstein moment for me.

 

It's the song that got me into them and was the only one I liked for a while so I get it, ha.

 

SOS

 

Now that remastered version of Smile In Your Seep they released in like 2014, that version holds up.

I wish I could re download it I lost mine lol

 

Man I'm finding out about a lot of releases I was oblivious to today.

 

Wait I was mistaken haha it was Smashed Into Pieces not Smile in your sleep

 

Hey everyone, if you were a fan of my bracket game on these threads or this one @js977 is running, and like the band My My Chemical Romance, that's the next game starting in about 30 minutes on the MCR thread.

 

Brookfield

 

It’s too late to rescue Brookfield but it fought valiantly. Here is our final tally for Short Songs:

SOS:7
Brookfield: 4

This sees SOS move on to the final. Stay tuned for Rescue (bracket is br00tal).

 

THIS IS HOW YOUR PERCEPTION OF OTHER USERS SHIFTS: THE SILVERSTEIN BRACKET CHALLENGE

For the uninitiated, these are randomly generated brackets (no seeding!) to determine a winner for each album, which will then face off in a Champions bracket to decide the best overall Silverstein song! Same rules as the other brackets:

Rules:
1. Voting will take place over 10-24 hour period, depending on how close the matches are (if there's a wide margin too far to beat the round may be run ruled to not waste time).
2. You must vote on every match in a round. If you don't your other votes don't count. Just reply to this thread with your choices. I will not vote unless there is a tie needed to be broken.
3. Feel free to discuss why you chose one song over the other and why you like that song. Question others, too. It's what helps keeps these fun!
4. I avoid byes into rounds if I can, but sometimes it's necessary. These are randomly generated; I do not pick them.
5. Once your votes are counted, signified by me 'liking' your post, there are no vote changes. Choose wisely before posting!

A word from he wise: People change in the brackets. Oh find the best song if you can. But be very wary, you might just lose yourself along the way.

SILVERSTEIN FACE OFF:
RESCUE
-----

Round 1

1) Good Luck With Your Lives Vs Intervention

2) Replace You Vs Forget Your Heart

3) Darling Harbour Vs Sacrifice

4) In Memory Of Vs Texas Mickey


Round 2

Winner of 1 Vs The Artist
Winner of 2 Vs Burning Hearts
Winner of 3 Vs Live To Kill
Winner of 4 Vs Medication


I think this record is criminally underrated and has some of their best songs so treat it as you would a child you care for. Not as much as your favorite child but after looking through old photos you realize you like it more than some of the other ones so you caress it a little more softly and hold it in higher esteem than you previously had. Just like that.

May the Round 1 voting begin!

 

Luck
Replace
Darling
Memory

 

Luck
Heart
Sacrifice
Texas

 

Good Luck
Replace You
Sacrifice - Awww man, this one was tough, I love both songs
Memory

 

Intervention
Replace (damn that was a tough one)
Sacrifice
Texas

 

Intervention
Replace You
Sacrifice (hardest choice)
Memory of

 

Intervention
Forget Your Heart
Darling Harbor
Texas Mickey

 

Intervention
Replace You
Sacrifice
Texas Mickey

 

Good Luck With Your Lives
Forget Your Heart
Darling Harbour
In Memory Of

 

Intervention
Forget Your Heart
Sacrifice
In Memory Of...

Some pretty tough decisions this round!

 

Intervention
Forget Your Heart
Sacrifice
Texas Mickey

Some tough choices. Replace You is a great fucking song especially acoustically, but I just love Forget Your Heart too much.