Say Anything - Oliver Appropriate (January 25, 2019) Album • Page 64

@SpyKi I said "OK" not "good"

 

S/T and Hebrews are the ones I go back to the most

 

More responding to other people saying it has good songs, ha.

 

I think the run from 17 Coked Up Speeding to Goshua is pretty great. I also really love the Bret Easton Ellis School. The rest is just kind of there for me, I honestly can't really remember most of them without listening. And I strongly dislike Give a Damn.

Hebrews is absolutely fantastic. I wholly love that album. It's a top 3 for me.

Anarchy didn't amaze me when I heard it, but I liked it, and I still like it now. Don't go back to it a ton, but when I do I always enjoy it.

I also love Oliver Appropriate. Listened to it quite a bit last year. It makes me feel a way. I enjoy the stripped back approach it has. Kind of felt like a fitting capstone for the band.

See you all at the Say Anything ...Is A Real Band Again 2022 Tour

 

Fine I'll do it

IARB > AMD > SA > IDOTG > OA > H > B > IDTII

 

IARB > IDOTG > H > SA/OA > AMD > B > IDTII

 

M/M ep
S/T
IARB
IDOTG
Hebrews
Oliver
Baseball
Anarchy
IDTII

this is the proper ranking don’t tell anyone different

 

If you haven’t ever thought about putting the M/M ep into your top 3 SA rankings you’re a nay nay.

 

I still think S/T is one of the best produced/mixed records of the scene circa 00-‘10

 

Honestly having anything other than IARB at number 1 is cray cray.

 

S/T has some of his best writing so I disagree. Also the ep has the best mix of angsty Max, and sad Max.

 

Self titled absolutely has some of his best writing but it's suuuper inconsistent. IARB is pretty much filled with his best writing.

 

S/T
IARB
Baseball
IDOTG
Anarchy
Hebrews
Oliver Appropriate
...
IDTII

 

Yeah IARB is still top for me but I like all the records. My rankings would change depending on what I've been listening to lately so I'm not going to do it again lol

 

S/T was a pretty important record for me. It really got me through my first year of high school, which I wasn't even in yet when it came out. I think it has his best songs by far and I love it from start to finish

 

“Cemetery” may be the best song Max has ever written.

 

I wouldn't necessarily disagree with this, and I know it's a common opinion that I respect. My favorite song on that album has always been Mara and Me. Musically, I love it, and lyrically I think it has everything that I love about Max's writing done almost perfectly.

I think the last part of Ahhh... Men might be my favorite lyrics he's ever written though. Idk. I just love that album so much haha

 

It's still my number 1.

 

...Is a Real Boy
In Defense of the Genre
Oliver Appropriate
Anarchy
Say Anything
Hebrews
Baseball
I Don't Think It Is

"So Numb" is a good song.

 

If you took out property > young dumb I think s/t would be a much stronger album k see ya

 

Love some of the songs on S/T, don't love others, but how clean it is actually kind of turns me off to it to this day. And I don't usually get that way about pop-leaning stuff. Just always felt a little sterile to me.

 

I still hate Do Better with all my fucking heart

 

No one is going to agree with me lol

IARB > IDOTG > IDTII > Hebrews > S/T > Anarchy > OA

 

IARB
S/T
Hebrews
Defense
Anarchy
Baseball
Oliver
IDTII

defense and anarchy are pretty interchangeable for me but I think Defense has some higher highs.

 

S/T has a few gems but a lot of cringe attempts at pop songs, Anarchy is incredibly forgettable, and I downright don’t like Oliver minus Pink Snot and Daze.